Aldi vs Walmart — Thanksgiving Dinner for 10, Exact Prices: $3.50 vs $3.90 a Plate

Two stores, two Thanksgiving baskets, one question: which feeds 10 people for less? This year both Aldi and Walmart have a Thanksgiving deal built around a whole turkey, the classic sides, rolls, and pumpkin pie — and the per-plate gap between them is just 40 cents.

Update, November 19, 2026: the American Farm Bureau Federation has published its 2026 Thanksgiving survey, and the national average for a classic dinner for 10 is $58.63 — about $5.86 a person, up 6% on last year and the first increase since 2022's record $64.05. The turkey is doing most of the damage: a 16-lb bird averages $23.68 ($1.48/lb), up 10%. Against that average, this week's Aldi list still feeds 10 for under $39 — roughly $20 less than the national average — and Walmart's $35 basket is the cheapest headline of the three, though its basket is smaller (a 13.5-lb turkey, and no mashed potatoes, green beans or mac & cheese in the list). The Aldi list below is unchanged; the Farm Bureau number just makes the saving clearer.

Here is the honest comparison, with the exact math up front.

The Headline Math

Walmart Holiday Meal Basket: $35 total, feeds 10, $3.50 per person exactly. Aldi Thanksgiving basket: under $39, feeds up to 10, under $3.90 per person. Sam's Club Thanksgiving meal (context): $160 before tax, feeds up to 16, $10.00 per person exactly.

The math: $35 divided by 10 = $3.50 per person exactly. $39 divided by 10 = $3.90 per person — and because Aldi's basket is under $39, Aldi's real per-plate figure is under $3.90 (the item-by-item sum below comes to $38.16, or $3.82 a plate). $160 divided by 16 = $10.00 per person exactly.

Rounding disclosure: Walmart's $3.50 and Sam's Club's $10.00 divide exactly, so there is no rounding gap on those two. Aldi's display figure ($3.90) is the advertised ceiling, not the item sum: 10 times $3.90 = $39.00, which is $0.84 above the $38.16 item sum. Aldi's exact item-sum per plate is $38.16 divided by 10 = $3.816, shown as $3.82.

Thanksgiving dinner table

Walmart: The $35 Holiday Meal Basket

Walmart's 2026 Holiday Meal Basket costs $35, feeds 10, and includes 26 items. The centerpiece is a Butterball turkey at 97 cents per lb (13.5-lb estimate — about $13.10 for the bird). Around it: Stove Top stuffing, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes with gravy, green bean casserole, sweet potato casserole, corn casserole, dinner rolls, pumpkin pie ingredients with whipped topping.

Available 28 October – 24 December 2026, in stores and online, with free Express Delivery through 30 November 2026. That long window is a real advantage: unlike Aldi's deal, which ends the day before Thanksgiving, Walmart's basket is still available through Christmas.

Price note: Only the Walmart basket total ($35) and the turkey price (97 cents/lb) are given here. A full item-by-item Walmart price list is not included — do not read the dish list above as a priced item list.

Aldi: The Under-$39 Basket (12 Items)

Aldi's 2026 Thanksgiving deal feeds up to 10 for under $39, announced 14 October 2026, running 14 October – 25 November 2026 (the day before Thanksgiving, 26 November). No coupons, loyalty cards, memberships, or minimum purchase required. In stores, the items are marked with a turkey logo on the shelf; the deal is also orderable online for curbside pickup or delivery.

Every price below is reused from the already-published Budget Bites Thanksgiving article — no new Aldi prices have been invented for this draft.

The centerpiece: Farmer's Choice whole turkey, 16 lb — from $15.84 (available early November, around Nov 4).

The sides: Stuffing mix, 3 boxes at $0.79 — $2.37. Baby carrots, 16 oz — $0.89. Celery, 1 lb — $0.95. Fresh cranberries, 12 oz — $0.95 (from Oct 26). Sweet potatoes, 3 lb — $1.95. Hawaiian sweet rolls, 12 count — $1.99. Steamable peas, 2 bags at $0.95 — $1.90.

The pie: Pumpkin pie mix — $1.99 (from Nov 11). Pie crusts, 2 count — $1.89. Whole milk, 1 gallon — $2.85 (listed $2.56–$2.85 across sources). Heavy whipping cream, 32 fl oz — $4.59.

Item sum: $38.16 — under $39, as advertised. Prices vary by store, so treat this as the plan, not a receipt.

Thanksgiving groceries

Side by Side: What Each Basket Includes — and What It Doesn't

Walmart ($35): feeds 10; 26 items; Butterball turkey, about 13.5 lb at 97c/lb; Stove Top stuffing; mashed potatoes + gravy; green bean casserole, sweet potato casserole, corn casserole; cranberry sauce; dinner rolls; pumpkin pie ingredients with whipped topping; gravy included; window 28 Oct – 24 Dec 2026; free Express Delivery through 30 Nov 2026.

Aldi (under $39): feeds up to 10; 12 items; Farmer's Choice turkey, 16 lb, from $15.84; stuffing mix x 3; sweet potatoes (3 lb); baby carrots, celery, steamable peas, sweet potatoes; fresh cranberries (make your own sauce); Hawaiian sweet rolls, 12 count; pumpkin pie mix + crusts + milk + cream; gravy NOT in the basket — budget a few dollars extra; window 14 Oct – 25 Nov 2026; no coupons, cards, or membership needed.

Where Walmart wins: the price — $35 beats under $39, and $3.50 a plate beats under $3.90. It also includes gravy and ready-style casserole sides, covers more dishes (26 items vs 12), and stays available through Christmas, with free Express Delivery through 30 November.

Where Aldi wins: the turkey — a 16-lb bird vs a roughly 13.5-lb bird, so there is more turkey per person and more leftovers. Aldi also needs no membership or loyalty card of any kind, and its fresh cranberries and sweet potatoes suit cooks who prefer to make sides from scratch rather than heat ready-style casseroles. Aldi's basket is also the one with a fully published item-by-item price list, so you can see exactly where every dollar goes.

The honest caveats: Aldi's basket is slightly shorter than its 2025 version — Aldi trimmed the item list while dropping the price by about a dollar — and it leaves gravy, butter for the rolls, and coffee outside the basket, so budget a few dollars more for those. Walmart's basket total is verified here as a total only; its 26-item breakdown has not been item-priced in this draft, so any claim about individual Walmart item prices would need checking first.

Thanksgiving cooking

Who Each Basket Suits

Pick Walmart if the lowest total matters most, you want gravy and casserole-style sides included, you want delivery, or you are shopping after Thanksgiving week — it runs to 24 December.

Pick Aldi if you want the biggest turkey, you like making cranberry sauce and sides from scratch, or you want a basket with no cards, coupons, or memberships attached.

Either way, both baskets feed 10 for less than a single fast-food combo costs per person — the 40-cent per-plate gap matters less than picking the basket whose sides match how your household actually cooks.

Family Thanksgiving meal

Context: Sam's Club Feeds 16 for $160

For a bigger crowd, Sam's Club's 2026 Thanksgiving meal is $160 before tax, feeds up to 16 — $10.00 per person — with a boneless carver ham and hickory-smoked turkey plus mashed potatoes, gravy, green beans, mac & cheese, corn, cranberry crunch salad, rolls, a charcuterie tray, and two pumpkin pies. It suits a crowd of 16 better than stretching a 10-person basket, but at $10.00 a plate it costs nearly three times the Walmart per-plate figure — the right choice only when the guest list genuinely needs 16 servings.

Read Next

Comments