BJ's Free Turkey Starts Today — and the Thanksgiving Ranking Just Changed

Thanksgiving dinner

The Short Version

Two things changed since our Thanksgiving ranking went live. First, BJ's free-turkey window opens today, 31 October: spend $150 or more in a single transaction by 9 November and a Butterball turkey worth up to $25 comes back to you as a coupon. Second, two newer bundles have moved the leaderboard — Lidl at $34.40 for 10 and Hy-Vee at under $35 for 10 both now sit ahead of, or level with, Walmart's $35.

The updated bundle ranking, cheapest plate first, is Lidl at $3.44, Hy-Vee at under $3.50, Walmart at $3.50, and Aldi at under $3.90. BJ's does not join that ranking as a number, because it is not a meal bundle — it is a free turkey on top of a shop. But for one specific shopper, it beats every bundle on the list. This article shows that math, and the exact condition it depends on.

The Updated Ranking at a Glance

RankDealTotalServesCost per plate
1Lidl (Nov 11–25 window)$34.4010$3.44
2Hy-Vee (Nov 2–Dec 24)Under $3510Under $3.50
3Walmart Holiday Meal Basket (through Dec 24)$3510$3.50
4AldiUnder $3910Under $3.90
—BJ's free turkeyNot a bundle — see below—Not rankable

Every per-plate figure below is the bundle total divided by the number of people it serves. Nothing else is baked into the math.

1. Lidl — $3.44 a Plate (New Leader)

$34.40 ÷ 10 people = $3.44 per person.

Lidl's figure for the 11–25 November window is $34.40 for 10, which works out to $3.44 a plate — 6¢ below Walmart's $3.50 and the new cheapest bundle plate on this list.

The $34.40 price requires an active Lidl Plus membership (free to join) with the app scanned at checkout, and it is based on a turkey of 14 lb or less — a heavier turkey raises the basket above $34.40.

A note on Lidl's earlier figure: our earlier ranking listed Lidl at $35.86. The $34.40 figure replaces $35.86 on Lidl's current Thanksgiving deal page (reported 30 October 2026): same 11–25 November window, same 14-lb turkey basket, now priced at $34.40 for Lidl Plus members. If you are shopping outside that window, do not assume $34.40 applies.

Who it wins for: A table of 10 shopping in the 11–25 November window. Six cents a plate is $0.60 across the whole table — small money, but it does make Lidl the cheapest bundle plate right now.

2. Hy-Vee — Under $3.50 a Plate

Under $35 ÷ 10 people = under $3.50 per person.

Hy-Vee's deal, announced 29 October 2026, runs 2 November to 24 December 2026 and feeds 10 for under $35. Because "under $35" is strictly below Walmart's exact $35, Hy-Vee's per-plate ceiling sits just under Walmart's $3.50 — but the exact total was not verified, so the exact per-plate figure is not stated here.

Who it wins for: A table of 10 with a Hy-Vee nearby, especially anyone shopping after 2 November. The long window through 24 December also covers a second holiday meal.

Watch out for: "Under $35" is a ceiling, not an exact price. The true per-plate figure could sit anywhere below $3.50 — close to Walmart, or a little further under.

Thanksgiving table

3. Walmart — $3.50 a Plate (Still the Benchmark)

$35 ÷ 10 people = $3.50 per person.

Walmart's Holiday Meal Basket, announced 28 October 2026, is $35 for 10 and runs through 24 December 2026. It drops from first to third on the new numbers, but only by cents — and it remains the bundle with no membership and no regional limit stated in the verified figures.

Who it wins for: Big tables of around 10 who want the lowest per-plate number without a membership question. If Lidl or Hy-Vee is not near you, Walmart's $3.50 is still the number to beat.

4. Aldi — Under $3.90 a Plate

Under $39 ÷ 10 people = under $3.90 per person.

Aldi's bundle feeds 10 for under $39, as covered in our earlier ranking and Aldi articles. It stays fourth on per-plate price — but it is still the bundle with the biggest turkey by weight in the earlier ranking (16 lb), if your crowd eats a lot of turkey.

BJ's Free Turkey: The Deal, Recapped

BJ's qualifying window opens today: spend $150 or more in a single transaction between 31 October and 9 November 2026, and you earn a free Butterball turkey worth up to $25. The coupon is issued from 14 November, and the turkey must be claimed by 25 November.

The full step-by-step mechanics — single-transaction rule, coupon timing, and who it works for — are in our BJ's explainer (linked under Read Next). What this article adds is the ranking question that explainer deliberately left open: what does a free turkey do to the per-plate math?

Thanksgiving turkey

The Scenario That Beats Every Bundle — and Its One Condition

Here is the honest version of the BJ's math. BJ's is not a meal, so it cannot be ranked as one. But a BJ's member can build a meal around it, and the arithmetic of that meal is worth showing — with every assumption labelled.

The scenario, step by step:

  1. The turkey costs $0 extra — but only if the $150 shop was spending you were going to do anyway. The $150 is real spending, not free money. The turkey's value back is at most $25.
  2. $25 ÷ $150 = 16.67%. At most, about one-sixth of the qualifying shop comes back as turkey value.
  3. The rest of the table still has to be bought. Our published Thanksgiving sides week prices a full sides-only shop for 10 at $22.32 — that is $2.23 a plate for sides alone, using the blog's published Aldi sides prices, not BJ's prices.
  4. $22.32 ÷ 10 people = $2.23 per person for the sides, with the turkey at $0 marginal cost.

The headline of the scenario: $2.23 a plate — below Lidl's $3.44, below Walmart's $3.50, below every bundle on the list.

But that headline is only true under one condition: the $150 BJ's shop must be real, planned spending. The moment you add spending just to reach $150, the math flips. Every extra dollar added only to hit the threshold is a dollar paid for the turkey — and the coupon is worth at most $25. If the extra spending you added exceeds $25, you paid more for the turkey than the coupon was ever worth. That is the trap in this deal, and it is the whole reason the condition matters.

So the scenario beats every bundle only for the shopper it was built for: a BJ's member whose normal shop already clears $150 inside the 31 October – 9 November window, who claims the coupon from 14 November and the turkey by 25 November, and who pairs it with a sides shop. For everyone else, the bundle ranking above stands unchanged — Lidl $3.44, Hy-Vee under $3.50, Walmart $3.50, Aldi under $3.90.

Thanksgiving dinner table

Who Wins Now, in One Paragraph Each

  • Cheapest bundle plate, table of 10: Lidl, $3.44 (11–25 November window).
  • Best ceiling under $3.50 with a long window: Hy-Vee, under $3.50 (2 November – 24 December).
  • Cheapest no-questions bundle: Walmart, $3.50 exact, through 24 December.
  • Biggest turkey, table of 10: Aldi, under $3.90, 16-lb turkey per the earlier ranking.
  • Cheapest plate of all — but only on one condition: BJ's member scenario, $2.23 a plate for sides with a $0-marginal turkey, and only if the $150 shop was planned spending anyway.

The pattern from the first ranking still holds: the cheapest plate goes to the biggest table. What changed is the top of the table — and the fact that a turkey deal, handled honestly, can undercut every bundle without being a bundle at all.

Read Next

Sources

Bundle prices, serving counts, and dates in this article come from the retailers' 2026 announcements as given in the verified brief for this follow-up (Walmart announced 28 October 2026; Hy-Vee announced 29 October 2026; Lidl 11–25 November window) and from the blog's own published articles for the Aldi figure, the BJ's mechanics, and the sides-week price. Where a figure was not verified, this article says so instead of stating it as fact.

Comments