The Copycat Cheddar's Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $95.93 Shop — $4.80 a Serving

a slice of savoury chicken pie with golden crust and shredded-chicken filling, served with a green salad, a foil tray of pie behind it

Cheddar's started with a class of 5th graders. In 1979, Aubrey Good and Doug Rogers opened the first Cheddar's Casual Cafe in Arlington, Texas — and the name came from a class of 5th graders the founders had asked for restaurant name ideas. The rule from day one was that the food was made from scratch, in the kitchen, every day. In 2015 the chain renamed itself Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen to say that out loud, and on March 27, 2017 Darden Restaurants — the Olive Garden and LongHorn parent — announced it would buy Cheddar's for $780 million plus $10 million in transaction costs; the deal closed on April 24, 2017, and today there are more than 170 Cheddar's locations in 28 states. The signature never changed — the pot pie, the ribs, the hand-breaded tenders, the Monte Cristo, and a menu that reads like an American kitchen, made from scratch.

This week cooks that whole board at home, for four people, five nights, from one $95.93 shop. That is $4.80 a serving — $19.19 a dinner — against $312.20 for the same five dinners bought at the restaurant. You save about $216, and nobody at the table will believe the pot pie came from your own oven.

The Exact Shop

One shop, 28 items, $95.93. Every price below is a grocery-listing price as of November 18, 2026, and the total adds up exactly — no rounding, no "about."

ItemPrice
Chicken breasts, 3 lb ($2.99/lb)$8.97
Pork baby back ribs, 2.5 lb ($4.49/lb)$11.23
Chicken tenders, 2 lb ($3.99/lb)$7.98
Shrimp, 1 lb ($7.99/lb)$7.99
Deli ham, 8 oz$3.49
Deli turkey, 8 oz$3.49
Swiss cheese, 8 oz$2.99
Potatoes, 5 lb$2.99
Carrots, 2 lb$1.49
Yellow onions, 3 lb$1.99
Chicken broth, 32 oz$1.99
Milk, 32 oz$1.99
Butter, 8 oz$2.99
Flour, 2 lb$1.49
Eggs, 12 ct$2.49
Mayonnaise, 16 oz$2.49
Honey, 12 oz$3.49
Cabbage, 1 head$1.49
Broccoli, 2 lb$2.99
Cheddar cheese, 8 oz$2.49
BBQ sauce, 18 oz$2.49
White bread, 1 loaf$2.49
Raspberry preserves, 10 oz$2.99
Long-grain rice, 1 lb$0.99
Limes, 4 ct$1.99
Graham crackers, 14 oz$2.99
Sweetened condensed milk, 14 oz$2.49
Vegetable oil, 24 oz$2.99
Total$95.93

The math: $95.93 ÷ 20 servings = $4.80 a serving. $95.93 ÷ 5 dinners = $19.19 a dinner. (A note on the pennies: $4.80 × 20 = $96.00 and $19.19 × 5 = $95.95, seven cents over and two cents over the shop total — both the per-serving figure and the per-dinner figure are rounded UP, from $4.7965 and $19.186, and the shop total of $95.93 is exact.) The lunch menu is NOT used in the takeout column — the comparison buys the full dinner entrées, not the cheaper lunch portions, because the home dinners are full dinner plates with all the sides. Cooking oil, salt, pepper, garlic powder, onion powder, paprika, pantry yellow mustard, sugar, cinnamon and vanilla are pantry staples and are not costed.

smoked baby back ribs piled in a metal tray, bones visible, charred edges

What Each Night Costs

The takeout column is the honest part, so here it is plainly: these are November 2026 listing averages for Cheddar's dinner entrées — six readings per entrée, four for the Monte Cristo, two for the Key Lime Pie slice — because every home dinner here is the same plate, sides included, exactly as the restaurant sells it. Prices vary by location, and the most approximate figure in the week is Friday's Key Lime Pie slice $7.14 (two readings, $4.99–$9.29, and the $9.29 reading may be a whole-pie price — disclosed, not hidden); Thursday's Monte Cristo $13.59 has the widest range among the entrées ($11.99–$16.89). They are listed in-store dinner prices, not delivery-app prices (a delivery-menu Key West Chicken & Shrimp reading of $19.49 was delivery-marked and excluded, and a Yelp Thornton menu running about 40% above every other source was excluded as systematically inflated). The home column is exact. And one portion note, stated honestly: the home week matches the restaurant's portions — Monday serves one pot pie slice a person with a house salad, Tuesday serves a half rack of ribs a person, Wednesday serves 8 oz of tenders a person, Thursday serves one full Monte Cristo a person, and Friday serves 6 oz of chicken plus 4 oz of shrimp a person over seasoned rice with a slice of Key Lime Pie. The saving is still about $216 even so.

NightAt home (this shop)At Cheddar's (takeout)
Monday — Homemade Chicken Pot Pie Night$19.19$47.64 (4 × Homemade Chicken Pot Pie $11.91)
Tuesday — Baby Back Ribs Night$19.19$66.28 (4 × Baby Back Ribs $16.57)
Wednesday — Chicken Tender Platter Night$19.19$54.92 (4 × Chicken Tender Platter $13.73)
Thursday — Monte Cristo Night$19.19$54.36 (4 × Monte Cristo $13.59)
Friday — Key West Chicken & Shrimp Night$19.19$89.00 (4 × Key West Chicken & Shrimp $15.11 + Key Lime Pie $7.14)
Total$95.93$312.20

Five dinners at the restaurant: $312.20. Five dinners from this shop: $95.93. You save $216.27 — call it about $216. Friday's Key West Chicken & Shrimp with Key Lime Pie is the single biggest saving of the week ($89.00 at the restaurant against $19.19 at home — $69.81 on one night alone), and Monday's Homemade Chicken Pot Pie is the smallest saving of the week ($28.45), and that is stated honestly here rather than hidden: even the cheapest entrée on this board costs $11.91 a person, so the week still comes out about $216 ahead because every night is an $11–$22 plate at the restaurant and a $19.19 dinner at home.

The Week at a Glance

  • Monday — Homemade Chicken Pot Pie Night: chicken, potatoes, carrots and onion in a creamy from-scratch sauce under a golden crust, with a house salad. ~42g protein.
  • Tuesday — Baby Back Ribs Night: half a rack of ribs a person, slow-cooked and honey-glazed, with broccoli cheese casserole and mashed potatoes. ~45g protein.
  • Wednesday — Chicken Tender Platter Night: four hand-breaded tenders a person, fresh-cut fries, coleslaw and honey mustard. ~48g protein.
  • Thursday — Monte Cristo Night: a ham, turkey and Swiss sandwich, battered and fried until golden, dusted with powdered sugar, served with raspberry preserves and a side salad. ~42g protein.
  • Friday — Key West Chicken & Shrimp Night: grilled chicken and shrimp over seasoned rice with a lime-and-onion pico, and a slice of Key Lime Pie. ~60g protein.

Average across the week: about 47g of protein per serving.

The Method

Five rules run the week.

  1. The chicken does three nights. Three pounds of chicken breasts are bought once. Monday takes half for the pot pie; Friday takes half for the Key West plate; and the tenders — two pounds, bought separately — do Wednesday. The chicken is the shop, so it does three nights.
  2. The potatoes do three nights. Five pounds of potatoes are bought once. Monday takes some for the pot pie; Tuesday takes some for the mash; Wednesday takes the rest for the fries. The potatoes are the shop, so they do three nights.
  3. The honey does three nights. One jar of honey is bought once. Tuesday takes some for the rib glaze; Wednesday takes some for the honey mustard; and the rest covers the rice pudding on Sunday. The honey is the shop, so it does three nights.
  4. The batter does two nights. One bowl — flour, eggs and milk — is mixed once. Wednesday takes it for the tenders; Thursday takes it for the Monte Cristo. The batter is the one thing the fried nights share, and it costs less than the coating it replaces.
  5. The limes do Friday. Four limes are bought once. Three go into the Key Lime Pie; one goes into the pico. The pie is made from scratch — graham crackers, condensed milk, lime juice and egg yolks — and Friday ends the week with a dessert the restaurant charges $7.14 a slice for.

Monday — Homemade Chicken Pot Pie Night

Cook the chicken breasts in the broth until cooked through, then shred them. Cook the potatoes, carrots and onion in the same broth until tender. Make the sauce — butter and flour cooked together, then milk and broth whisked in until thick — and stir in the chicken and the vegetables. Pour it into a baking dish, lay the crust over the top — rolled from the flour, butter and milk, or a store-bought crust if the week is tight — crimp the edges, cut vents, and bake until golden and bubbling. Toss the lettuce and the spare onion into a small house salad, and serve the pie with the salad. The from-scratch filling is what makes the night — a bought filling with no scratch is just a pie, and the from-scratch filling is the whole reason Monday is the pot pie night. Storage note: Cooked pot pie keeps 3 days in the fridge; reheat it in the oven, not the microwave, so the crust stays crisp. Per serving: $4.80 a serving (the night costs $19.19; divide by four).

Tuesday — Baby Back Ribs Night

Rub the ribs with salt, pepper, paprika and garlic powder from the pantry, then slow-cook them — in the oven, low and covered — until tender. Brush them with the honey BBQ glaze — BBQ sauce whisked with honey — and finish them under the grill until sticky. While they cook, make the broccoli cheese casserole — broccoli, cheddar, milk and butter baked together — and mash the potatoes with butter and milk. Serve the ribs with the casserole and the mash. The honey glaze is what makes the night — plain ribs with no glaze are just ribs, and the honey glaze is the whole reason Tuesday is the ribs night. Storage note: Cooked ribs keep 3 days in the fridge; reheat them gently in the oven, covered, so they stay tender. The casserole keeps 3 days — reheat it in the oven. Per serving: $4.80 a serving (the night costs $19.19; divide by four).

golden breaded fried chicken strips piled in a wire basket

Wednesday — Chicken Tender Platter Night

Cut the tenders into strips — four large ones a person — dredge them in seasoned flour, dip in egg, dredge again, and fry in the hot oil until golden and cooked through. Cut the potatoes into fries and fry them in the same oil until crisp. Toss the coleslaw — shredded cabbage and carrots with mayonnaise and lime — and whisk the honey mustard — honey, mayonnaise and pantry yellow mustard. Serve the tenders with the fries, the slaw and the honey mustard. The honey mustard is what makes the night — plain tenders with no sauce are just chicken, and the honey mustard is the whole reason Wednesday is the tenders night. Storage note: Cooked tenders keep 3 days in the fridge; reheat them in a hot oven so the coating stays crisp. Per serving: $4.80 a serving (the night costs $19.19; divide by four).

Thursday — Monte Cristo Night

Layer the ham, turkey and Swiss between slices of white bread — two sandwiches a person, cut in half — then dip each sandwich in the batter — flour, eggs and milk — and fry in the hot oil until golden on both sides and the cheese melts. Dust with powdered sugar from the pantry, warm the raspberry preserves, and toss the lettuce and the spare onion into a small side salad. Serve the Monte Cristo with the preserves for dipping and the salad. The raspberry preserves are what makes the night — a fried sandwich with no preserves is just a toastie, and the raspberry preserves are the whole reason Thursday is the Monte Cristo night. Storage note: The Monte Cristo does not keep — the batter goes soft in the fridge, so Thursday is a cook-and-eat night. Per serving: $4.80 a serving (the night costs $19.19; divide by four).

Friday — Key West Chicken & Shrimp Night

Grill the chicken breasts until marked and cooked through, then rest them and slice them. Grill the shrimp — 4 oz a person — until pink. Cook the seasoned rice — long-grain rice simmered with onion and pantry spices — and toss the pico — diced onion, lime juice and a little garlic powder. Make the Key Lime Pie — graham cracker crust, condensed milk, lime juice and egg yolks, baked and chilled — and serve the chicken and shrimp over the rice with the pico and a slice of pie. The pie is what makes the night — a chicken-and-shrimp plate with no dessert is just a dinner, and the Key Lime Pie is the whole reason Friday is the Key West night. Storage note: The pie keeps 3 days in the fridge and tastes better cold; the chicken and shrimp keep 2 days — reheat them gently in the pan. Per serving: $4.80 a serving (the night costs $19.19; divide by four).

3 Variations (From the Spares)

  1. Honey-mustard egg salad sandwiches — Saturday lunch. Chop the spare eggs with the spare mayonnaise and the spare honey, and spoon it onto the spare bread. The Wednesday sauce, on eggs, for lunch.
  2. Cabbage fritters with onion — Sunday lunch. Shred the spare cabbage and the spare onion, mix with the spare flour and a spare egg, and fry in the spare oil until crisp. The Wednesday slaw's spares, rebuilt as fritters, with no extra shop.
  3. Honey rice pudding — Sunday supper. Simmer the spare rice in the spare milk with the spare honey until thick. The Friday rice's spares, rebuilt as a pudding, for the last night of the week.

Why This Works

  • The chicken does three nights. Three pounds of breasts and two pounds of tenders are bought once, and they carry Monday, Wednesday and Friday — which is why the per-dinner cost stays at $19.19 even on the nights with $22 plates. The chicken is the shop, so it does three nights. The potatoes are the second shop, so they do three nights too.
  • Friday is the most expensive single night on the board. A Key West Chicken & Shrimp with a Key Lime Pie for four costs about $89.00 at the restaurant — the home version is $19.19 for four, and Friday alone saves about $69.81. Nothing else in the shop does that much work for that little money — the chicken, the shrimp and the pie all come from the same shop, which is the whole reason the week beats Cheddar's by about $216.
  • One shop, five completely different dinners. A pot pie, ribs, tenders, a Monte Cristo, and a chicken-and-shrimp plate with pie — the main changes every night (pie, ribs, tenders, sandwich, chicken-and-shrimp), so the week never tastes like the same dinner five times, even though the same twenty-eight items supply all of it.
  • It beats Cheddar's by about $216. Five nights at Cheddar's for a family of four run about $312.20. This week is $95.93, the pot pie still comes out of your own oven, and the Friday plate gives a Key West Chicken & Shrimp with a Key Lime Pie for $19.19.
  • Every dinner carries 42g of protein or more a serving. Monday and Thursday trail at about 42g, Friday leads at about 60g, and the week averages about 47g — the menu changes, the protein doesn't drop below a pot pie share.
a slice of Key Lime Pie with whipped cream and a graham crust, the whole pie behind it

The Bottom Line

$95.93. Five dinners for four, $4.80 a serving, $19.19 a dinner — the Homemade Chicken Pot Pie with the house salad, the Baby Back Ribs with the broccoli cheese casserole, the Chicken Tender Platter with the honey mustard, the Monte Cristo with the raspberry preserves, and the Friday Key West Chicken & Shrimp with the Key Lime Pie, every one of them from the chain that started in 1979 in Arlington, Texas, named by a class of 5th graders and built on food made from scratch, with about 47g of protein a serving on average, and about $216 less than the same five dinners at Cheddar's. Ninety-five dollars is not a tight week. It is five real dinners, with the pie, the ribs, the tenders, the sandwich and the chicken-and-shrimp — the whole Cheddar's board, cooked at home, for less than the price of one Friday plate bought out. And the Key Lime Pie comes free.

Read Next

Comments