The Copycat Cook Out Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $88.38 Shop — $4.42 a Serving

The Copycat Cook Out Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $88.38 Shop — $4.42 a Serving

Cook Out started in a double drive-thru. In 1989, Morris Reaves, a former Wendy's franchisee in North Carolina's Triad region, opened the first Cook Out on Randleman Road in Greensboro, North Carolina, with one idea: char-grilled burgers at fair prices, and more food per dollar than any competitor. The idea became the tray — one main, two sides and a drink for one price, with more than 54,000 possible combinations — and the tray became the chain: more than 350 locations across ten southeastern states, still privately held by the Reaves family, with a milkshake menu of more than 40 flavours that turns the tray's drink into a dessert.

Double cheeseburger with melted cheese on a wooden board

This week cooks that whole tray at home, for four people, five nights, from one $88.38 shop. That is $4.42 a serving — $17.68 a dinner — against $156.20 for the same five trays bought at the window. You save about $68, and nobody at the table will believe the tray came from your own kitchen.

The Exact Shop

One shop, 25 items, $88.38. Every price below is a grocery-listing price as of November 17, 2026, and the total adds up exactly — no rounding, no "about."

ItemPrice
Ground beef 80/20, 4 lb ($3.89/lb)$15.56
Pork shoulder, 3 lb ($2.49/lb)$7.47
Chicken tenders, 2 lb ($3.49/lb)$6.98
All-beef hot dogs, 8 ct$3.49
Bacon, 12 oz$4.99
Hamburger buns, 8 ct × 2 ($2.49 each)$4.98
Hot dog buns, 8 ct$2.49
Flour tortillas, 10 ct$2.49
Sliced cheddar, 8 oz$2.49
Monterey Jack, 8 oz$2.99
Eggs, 12 ct$2.49
All-purpose flour, 5 lb$2.99
Cornmeal, 2 lb$1.99
Frozen crinkle-cut fries, 32 oz$3.49
Yellow onions, 2 lb$1.49
Lettuce, 1 head$1.49
Tomatoes, 1.5 lb$1.49
Dill pickles, 16 oz$1.99
Cabbage, 1 head$1.29
Carrots, 1 lb$1.29
Vanilla ice cream, 48 oz$4.49
Whole milk, 1/2 gal$2.99
BBQ sauce, 18 oz$2.49
Mayonnaise, 16 oz$2.49
Canned chili, 15 oz$1.99
Total$88.38

The math: $88.38 ÷ 20 servings = $4.42 a serving. $88.38 ÷ 5 dinners = $17.68 a dinner. (A note on the pennies: $4.42 × 20 = $88.40 and $17.68 × 5 = $88.40, two cents over the shop total — the per-serving and per-dinner figures are rounded up from $4.419 and $17.676, and the shop total of $88.38 is exact.)

Pulled pork barbecue sandwich with coleslaw

What Each Night Costs

The takeout column is the honest part: these are November 2026 listing averages for Cook Out trays — one main, two sides and a drink — because every home dinner here is a tray too, sides and drink included, exactly as Cook Out sells them. Tray prices vary by location and by main, and the two single-reading tray prices (2 Hot Dogs Tray $6.29, Huge Burger Tray $9.49) are the most approximate figures in the week. They are listed menu prices, not delivery-app prices (delivery apps run higher). The home column is exact.

NightAt home (this shop)At Cook Out (takeout)
Monday — Big Double Burger Night$17.68$31.96 (4 × Big Double Burger Tray $7.99)
Tuesday — BBQ Sandwich Night$17.68$31.56 (4 × BBQ Sandwich Tray $7.89)
Wednesday — Chicken Strips Night$17.68$29.56 (4 × Chicken Strips Tray $7.39)
Thursday — Cook Out Style Hot Dog Night$17.68$25.16 (4 × 2 Hot Dogs Tray $6.29)
Friday — Huge Burger Tray Night$17.68$37.96 (4 × Huge Burger Tray $9.49)
Total$88.38$156.20

Five trays at the window: $156.20. Five trays from this shop: $88.38. You save $67.82 — call it about $68. Friday's Huge Burger tray is the single biggest saving of the week ($37.96 at the window against $17.68 at home), and Thursday's hot-dog tray is the cheapest night to buy ($25.16) — which is also why Thursday is the smallest saving of the week, stated honestly here rather than hidden: Cook Out is already the cheapest counter in the series, so the saving is the smallest in the series too, and the week still comes out about $68 ahead.

The Week at a Glance

  • Monday — Big Double Burger Night: two char-grilled patties with cheese, pickles, lettuce and grilled onion, fries and hushpuppies on the side. ~42g protein.
  • Tuesday — BBQ Sandwich Night: slow-cooked chopped pork barbecue with vinegar slaw on a bun, fries and hushpuppies on the side. ~38g protein.
  • Wednesday — Chicken Strips Night: hand-breaded chicken strips with two dipping sauces, fries and hushpuppies on the side. ~38g protein.
  • Thursday — Cook Out Style Hot Dog Night: two char-grilled dogs each with chili, slaw, mustard and onion, fries and hushpuppies on the side. ~30g protein.
  • Friday — Huge Burger Tray Night: the Huge Burger with bacon and cheese, fries, hushpuppies, quesadilla wedges and a vanilla milkshake. ~45g protein.

Average across the week: about 39g of protein per serving.

The Method

Five rules run the whole week. Learn them once and every night is a tray, not a new recipe.

Rule 1 — The beef does two nights. The 4 lb of ground beef is the week's engine. Monday takes 2 lb for eight quarter-pound patties, Friday takes 2 lb for four half-pound Huge Burgers. Buy it once, split it once, and the two burger nights cost one shop.

Rule 2 — The pork cooks once and feeds Tuesday. The 3 lb pork shoulder slow-cooks Tuesday morning and shreds by dinner. No other night touches it — Tuesday is the barbecue night, and the shoulder is the whole of it.

Rule 3 — Fry once, serve twice. The fries and the hushpuppies are the tray's second side every night they fit. Fry one batch, serve it hot, and never fry a fresh batch for a second helping — the tray is one fry, not two.

Rule 4 — The shake is Friday's finish, not a side. The ice cream and milk stay in the freezer and the fridge until Friday. A shake on Monday is a dessert; a shake on Friday is the tray's drink upgrade, the way Cook Out sells it.

Rule 5 — Build the tray, don't plate the parts. Every dinner is a main plus two sides, served together. Don't serve the burger now and the fries later — the tray is the dinner, and the tray arrives at once.

Monday — Big Double Burger Night

Form the 2 lb of ground beef into eight quarter-pound patties, season with salt and pepper, and char-grill them until cooked through — two patties per person. Toast 4 hamburger buns. For each person: a double burger with sliced cheddar, dill pickles, lettuce and grilled onion, with crinkle-cut fries and hushpuppies on the side. Storage: cooked patties keep 3 days in the fridge; reheat them in a covered pan so they stay juicy.

Tuesday — BBQ Sandwich Night

Slow-cook the 3 lb pork shoulder until it shreds — low heat, about 4 hours, the home version of Cook Out's slow-cooked chopped pork. Shred it, toss it with the BBQ sauce, and make the vinegar slaw from the cabbage, carrots, mayonnaise and a splash of vinegar. Toast 4 hamburger buns. For each person: 12 oz of chopped pork barbecue with slaw on a bun, with fries and hushpuppies on the side. Storage: cooked pork keeps 3–4 days in the fridge in its sauce; it freezes well for up to 3 months.

Crispy chicken strips with fries and dipping sauces

Wednesday — Chicken Strips Night

Cut the 2 lb of chicken tenders into strips, dredge them in the flour with an egg wash, and fry them until golden and cooked through — 8 oz per person. Mix the two dipping sauces from the mayonnaise and the BBQ sauce. For each person: chicken strips with both dips, fries and hushpuppies on the side. Storage: cooked strips keep 2 days in the fridge; reheat them in the oven, not the microwave, so they stay crisp.

Thursday — Cook Out Style Hot Dog Night

Grill the 8 all-beef hot dogs (two each) and warm 8 hot dog buns. Heat the canned chili. For each person: two dogs with chili, slaw, yellow mustard and chopped onion — Cook Out Style, no ketchup on top of the chili. Fries and hushpuppies on the side. Storage: cooked hot dogs keep 3 days in the fridge; the buns keep in their bag on the counter.

Friday — Huge Burger Tray Night

Form the last 2 lb of ground beef into four half-pound patties, season with salt and pepper, and char-grill them until cooked through. Fry the bacon until crisp. Toast the last 4 hamburger buns. Grill the quesadilla wedges from the spare tortillas and the Monterey Jack. For the vanilla milkshake: blend the vanilla ice cream with the whole milk until thick — one shake per person. Each tray: a Huge Burger with bacon and sliced cheddar, fries, hushpuppies, quesadilla wedges and a vanilla milkshake. Storage: the shake is made to order and does not keep; the bacon keeps 3 days in the fridge.

3 Variations (From the Spares)

The shop leaves spares on purpose — 4 hamburger buns, 6 tortillas, eggs, cheese, milk, ice cream, flour, cornmeal, onions and pickles. Three more meals, no extra shop:

  1. Milkshake Saturday — the spare ice cream and milk. Blend a thick vanilla shake per person, the way Friday's tray ends. The ice cream was already in the shop; the dessert costs nothing extra.
  2. Quesadilla Sunday lunch — the spare tortillas and the Monterey Jack with the sliced cheddar. Grill a cheese quesadilla per person with pickles on the side. Lunch for four, from leftovers.
  3. Bacon & Egg Roll, Sunday supper — the spare hamburger buns, the last bacon and the spare eggs. Fry an egg and the bacon per person and serve them hot on a bun with mayonnaise. The week's cheapest dinner, and the one that uses the last of the shop.

Why This Works

One tray feeds five nights — that is the whole trick. The tray is the most expensive idea in the shop, and it is also the cheapest: every dinner is a main plus two sides, and the sides — fries, hushpuppies, quesadilla wedges — come from the same flour, cornmeal and potatoes as the mains. The ground beef is the most expensive item in the shop at $15.56, and it carries Monday and Friday, which is why the per-dinner cost stays at $17.68 even on the nights with the biggest burgers. The pork shoulder is the cheapest protein in the shop at $7.47 for 3 lb, and it carries Tuesday whole. And Friday's tray, the one that would cost $37.96 at the window, costs the same $17.68 as every other night, because the Huge Burger, the bacon, the quesadilla wedges and the shake all come from the same shop. That is the Cook Out tray at home: the same five trays, the same flavours, $68 cheaper — the smallest saving in the series, stated honestly, because Cook Out is already the cheapest counter in the series, and the week still comes out ahead.

Storage

  • Burgers and patties: 3 days cooked in the fridge; reheat in a covered pan so they stay juicy. Freeze uncooked patties for up to 3 months.
  • Pork barbecue: 3–4 days in the fridge in its sauce; freeze for up to 3 months.
  • Chicken strips: 2 days cooked in the fridge; reheat in the oven, not the microwave, so they stay crisp.
  • Hot dogs: 3 days cooked in the fridge; freeze uncooked for up to 2 months.
  • Buns and tortillas: freeze in their bags for up to 3 months; thaw at room temperature.
  • Milkshake: made to order, does not keep. Ice cream keeps to its printed date in the freezer.

Vanilla milkshakes with toppings

The Bottom Line

Five Cook Out trays for four, one $88.38 shop, $4.42 a serving, about $68 saved against the window. The Big Double is the dinner to remember — two char-grilled patties, cheese, pickles, lettuce and grilled onion, with hushpuppies on the side — but the week works because the whole tray comes from one shop: the burgers, the barbecue, the strips, the dogs and the Huge Burger with its milkshake, all of it, for less than the cost of two trays bought out. Cook it once and the double drive-thru on Randleman Road feels a lot closer than Greensboro.

Want more plans like this?

Read next: The Copycat P.F. Chang's Week — $4.00 a Serving · The Copycat Portillo's Week — $4.31 a Serving · The Copycat Noodles & Company Week — $3.91 a Serving

Comments