The Copycat Sonic Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $55.96 Shop — $2.80 a Serving

Three golden-brown breaded corn dogs on wooden skewers on a white plate with a dipping sauce

Sonic is the one drive-thru the other chains in this series never touched — the carhop place with the corn dogs, the tater tots and the hand-spun shakes. This week cooks all five of those dinners at home. Corn dogs with tots on Monday, chili cheese tots on Tuesday, double smash burgers with crinkle fries on Wednesday, crispy chicken strips with Texas toast on Thursday, and popcorn chicken with pickle fries and vanilla milkshakes on Friday.

Five dinners for four, one $55.96 shop, $2.80 a serving — and about 26g of protein a serving on average. The same five dinners at Sonic run about $180.96. This week beats that by exactly $125. The trick is the same one Sonic uses: the menu is built from a handful of pieces — tots, beef, chicken, buns and a breading station — that just change shape every night.

The Exact Shop

Item Price (approx. US supermarket)
Frozen corn dogs, 8 ct $4.49
Frozen tater tots, 32 oz $2.99
Honey mustard, 12 oz $1.99
Canned chili, no beans, 15 oz $1.99
Shredded cheddar, 8 oz $2.49
Fresh jalapeños, 2 $0.59
Sour cream, 8 oz $1.49
Ground beef 80/20, 1.5 lb $5.99
Burger buns, 8 ct $1.99
Sliced American cheese, 12 ct $2.49
Frozen crinkle fries, 28 oz $2.49
Roma tomatoes, 2 $0.98
Iceberg lettuce, 1 head $1.29
Chicken breast, 2 lb $6.98
Frozen Texas toast, 8 ct $2.49
Panko breadcrumbs, 8 oz $1.49
Dill pickles, 16 oz jar $1.99
Vanilla ice cream, 48 oz $3.49
Whole milk, ½ gal $1.99
Buttermilk, 1 qt $2.49
All-purpose flour, 2 lb $1.29
Eggs, 12 ct $2.49
Total $55.96

The math: $4.49 + $2.99 + $1.99 + $1.99 + $2.49 + $0.59 + $1.49 + $5.99 + $1.99 + $2.49 + $2.49 + $0.98 + $1.29 + $6.98 + $2.49 + $1.49 + $1.99 + $3.49 + $1.99 + $2.49 + $1.29 + $2.49 = $55.96. Five dinners for four = 20 servings. $55.96 ÷ 20 = $2.80 a serving. $55.96 ÷ 5 = $11.19 a dinner for four. The same five dinners at Sonic run about $180.96 — this week beats that by exactly $125. Cooking oil, salt, pepper, garlic powder, paprika, cayenne, mustard, ketchup and vanilla extract are pantry staples and are not costed. The flour and eggs are costed this week because the breading station needs them — the same convention as the Burger King week. The beef is the priciest item in the shop at $5.99 for the whole week — Wednesday is the burger night, and it earns it.

Golden tater tots in a paper tray with a dip cup and parsley

What Each Night Costs

Night Dinner Protein per serving (approx.) As takeout for four At home
Monday Corn dogs with tater tots + honey mustard ~16g ~$31.96 $11.19
Tuesday Chili cheese tater tots with jalapeños + sour cream ~14g ~$18.36 $11.19
Wednesday Double smash burgers with crinkle fries ~36g ~$43.96 $11.19
Thursday Crispy chicken strips with Texas toast + honey mustard ~32g ~$30.72 $11.19
Friday Popcorn chicken with pickle fries + vanilla milkshakes ~34g ~$55.96 $11.19
Week total 5 dinners, 20 servings ~26g average ~$180.96 $55.96

The saving: $180.96 − $55.96 = $125.00 — exactly $125 back in your pocket for the same five dinners. Every takeout price above is approximate: the Sonic prices are typical US Sonic menu prices from independent menu guides (corn dog ~$2.49, medium tots ~$2.99, medium chili cheese tots ~$4.59, SuperSONIC Double Cheeseburger ~$7.99, 5-piece Super Crunch Chicken Strips ~$4.69, Premium Chicken Bites ~$5.79, classic shake ~$4.49 per person), prices vary by location, and tax is extra at the restaurant. The comparison is like for like — entrées only, no drinks — and the home dinners are bigger: two corn dogs each on Monday, a full tray of loaded tots each on Tuesday, two smashed patties each on Wednesday, and a milkshake each on Friday, with seconds for anyone who wants them. One honest note: Tuesday is the lightest protein night of the week at about 14g a serving — loaded tots are a snack that got promoted to dinner, and the chili and cheese do what they can — while Wednesday is the heaviest at about 36g, because two smashed patties plus two slices of cheese do the work on their own. Friday does the heavy lifting on the saving — the popcorn chicken, pickle fries and shake plate is the priciest plate on the board at about $13.99 a serving, and the home version saves about $44 that night alone — and the week still comes out exactly $125 ahead.

The Week at a Glance

  • Monday — Corn dogs with tater tots + honey mustard (~16g protein): The fairground night. Frozen corn dogs baked until the batter is crisp, with a tray of golden tots and honey mustard for dipping. The drive-thru's cheapest dinner, cooked at home, with better tots.
  • Tuesday — Chili cheese tater tots with jalapeños + sour cream (~14g protein): The loaded night. The rest of the tots baked crisp, piled high with warm canned chili, shredded cheddar, sliced jalapeños and a dollop of sour cream. The snack that got promoted to dinner.
  • Wednesday — Double smash burgers with crinkle fries (~36g protein): The big night. Eight thin smashed patties — two per burger — seared hard in a screaming-hot pan with crispy edges, stacked on plain buns with two slices of American cheese, tomato, lettuce, pickles and mustard, with a tray of crinkle fries from the oven. The burger that built the chain's reputation, at home.
  • Thursday — Crispy chicken strips with Texas toast + honey mustard (~32g protein): The dippable night. Chicken breast brined in buttermilk, dredged in flour, egg and panko and fried until deep golden, with thick slices of buttery Texas toast and honey mustard for dipping. The strips are the dinner — the toast is the point.
  • Friday — Popcorn chicken with pickle fries + vanilla milkshakes (~34g protein): The finish night. Bite-size popcorn chicken from the last of the breast, fried crisp in the same breading, with pickle fries — dill pickle slices dredged and fried — and a hand-spun vanilla milkshake each. The drive-thru dessert, poured at home.

The Method

The Sonic rules — the same five rules, every night:

1. The tots are the through-line. Monday's side is Tuesday's dinner. One 32 oz bag of tots covers both nights — 16 oz beside the corn dogs, 16 oz under the chili and cheese — so the cheapest item in the shop does two nights' work.

2. One breading station, two nights. Thursday's strips and Friday's popcorn chicken share the same buttermilk soak and the same flour, egg and panko. Set the station up once, use it twice — a breading station that only gets used once is a waste.

3. The pan does the smashing. Wednesday's patties get pressed flat in a screaming-hot pan and left alone — pressing squeezes the juices out, and the crispy edges come from leaving them alone. No press, no grill, no special equipment.

4. Friday cooks the fun stuff last. The shakes get blended while the popcorn chicken rests, and the pickle fries come out of the oil last so they are still shatteringly crisp when the shakes hit the table. Cold shake, hot fries — that contrast is the whole Friday dinner.

5. The spares are next week's head start. Four spare buns, four spare cheese slices, half the sour cream, half the ice cream, the rest of the milk, the rest of the flour and eight spare eggs. Small spares, all of them useful, none of them wasted.

Monday — Corn dogs with tater tots + honey mustard: Heat the oven to 425°F and get the 16 oz of tots on a tray first — they need the full 20 minutes. Put the 8 frozen corn dogs on the same tray for the last 15 minutes, turning once, until the batter is crisp and golden. Pour the honey mustard into a bowl for dipping. Serve two corn dogs each with a pile of tots. The tots set the clock — everything else is timed to the tray coming out.

Storage note: The corn dogs keep 1 day in the fridge and reheat in the oven, not the microwave — the microwave turns the batter soft; the tots do not keep — cook them fresh on the night.

Tuesday — Chili cheese tater tots with jalapeños + sour cream: Heat the oven to 425°F and bake the remaining 16 oz of tots on a tray until deep golden and crisp, about 20 minutes. While they bake, warm the 15 oz of canned chili in a small pot and slice the 2 jalapeños into thin rings. Tip the hot tots into a wide bowl, spoon the chili over the top, scatter the shredded cheddar over it so it melts, and finish with the jalapeño rings and a dollop of sour cream. Serve in bowls, straight from the bowl. The tots want to be hot when the chili goes on — cold tots under hot chili go soggy, hot tots under hot chili stay crisp underneath.

Make-ahead: The jalapeños can be sliced on Monday night — Tuesday is bake, warm, pile, eat.

Stacked smash burger with smashed patties, melted cheese, tomato and lettuce on a bun

Wednesday — Double smash burgers with crinkle fries: Heat the oven to 450°F and get the 28 oz of crinkle fries on a tray first — they need the full 15 minutes. While they bake, divide the 1.5 lb of beef into eight 3-oz balls. Get a cast-iron pan or heavy skillet as hot as it will go, with just a film of oil, and smash each ball flat with a spatula — press hard, once, then leave it alone 2 minutes a side until the edges are dark and crispy. Stack two patties per burger with a slice of American cheese on each, so the cheese melts between them. Slice the 2 Roma tomatoes and shred the lettuce. Build the burgers on the plain buns: mustard and ketchup on both halves, then the double stack, tomato, lettuce and pickles from the jar. Serve with the fries. The smash is what makes the burger — a thick patty steams, a smashed patty crisps.

Storage note: The cooked patties keep 2 days in the fridge and reheat in a pan; the fries do not keep — cook them fresh on the night.

Thursday — Crispy chicken strips with Texas toast + honey mustard: Slice 1 lb of chicken breast into strips and soak them in the buttermilk with salt, pepper, garlic powder and paprika for at least 30 minutes — overnight if you can. Set up the breading station: flour seasoned with salt, pepper, garlic powder and paprika in one dish, 2 beaten eggs in the second, panko in the third. Dredge each strip through flour, egg and panko, pressing the crumbs on firmly, and fry in batches in hot oil until deep golden — about 3 minutes a strip. While they fry, bake the 8 slices of Texas toast according to the box. Pour the honey mustard into a bowl for dipping. Serve the strips with two slices of toast each. The buttermilk soak is what keeps fast-food chicken juicy under a crunchy crust — skip it and the strips go dry.

Storage note: The strips keep 2 days in the fridge and reheat best in the oven, not the microwave — the microwave turns the panko soft.

Friday — Popcorn chicken with pickle fries + vanilla milkshakes: Cut the last 1 lb of chicken breast into bite-size pieces and soak them in the rest of the buttermilk while the oil heats. Run them through the same breading station as Thursday — flour, egg, panko — and fry in batches until deep golden, about 2 minutes a batch. While they fry, slice half the pickles from the jar into spears, dredge them through the leftover flour and panko, and fry until crisp — about 1 minute. Blend the shakes last: 24 oz of vanilla ice cream with 2 cups of milk and a splash of vanilla extract, until thick and pourable. Serve the popcorn chicken with the pickle fries and a shake each. The shakes want to be blended last — blended early they melt, blended last they are thick enough to need a straw and a spoon.

Storage note: The popcorn chicken keeps 1 day in the fridge and reheats in the oven; the pickle fries do not keep — fry them fresh and eat them hot; the shakes do not keep — blend them fresh on the night.

3 Variations (no extra shop)

  • Spicy chili cheese tots Tuesday: Slice the jalapeños with the seeds left in and stir a pinch of cayenne from the pantry into the chili before it goes on the tots. Same $55.96 shop, same tots, and the mildest night of the week suddenly has a kick — the kids can pick the jalapeños off their own bowls and the adults take the spicy ones.
  • Extra-cheesy smash burgers Wednesday: Put the 4 spare American cheese slices on the burgers instead of saving them — three slices per burger instead of two. Same shop, same burgers, and Wednesday's dinner comes out richer and gooier instead of plain — the cheese that was going to wait for next week does its work on the patties instead.
  • Chocolate shakes Friday: Stir a spoonful of cocoa powder from the pantry into the shakes before blending instead of vanilla. Same $55.96 shop, same popcorn chicken, and Friday's finish comes out chocolate instead of vanilla — the milk and ice cream that were going to make vanilla shakes make chocolate ones instead.

Why This Works

  • Sonic's whole menu is four moves: A corn dog, a tot, a smashed patty and a breaded strip. One shop covers all five dinners because the menu itself is built from the same few pieces — the tots, the beef, the chicken and the breading station just change shape every night.
  • The freezer aisle does the cooking: Frozen corn dogs, frozen tots, frozen fries, frozen Texas toast. Nothing in this shop needs long cooking — the longest dinner is Wednesday's fries, and they cook themselves in the oven.
  • One shop, five completely different dinners: Corn dogs, loaded tots, double smash burgers, chicken strips with toast, popcorn chicken with shakes — the method changes every night (bake, pile, smash, fry, blend), so the week never tastes like the same dinner five times, even though the same twenty-two items supply all of it.
  • It beats Sonic by exactly $125: Five nights at the counter for a family of four run about $180.96. This week is $55.96, the dinners are bigger, the portions are full, and the shakes are poured at home.
  • Every dinner carries 14g of protein or more a serving: Tuesday trails at about 14g, Wednesday leads at about 36g, and the week averages about 26g — the menu changes, the protein doesn't drop.

Storage

  • Fridge: The corn dogs keep 1 day and reheat in the oven; the cooked smash patties keep 2 days and reheat in a pan; the chicken strips and popcorn chicken keep 2 days and 1 day respectively and reheat in the oven so the coating stays crisp; the chili keeps 3 days and reheats in a pot; the sour cream, milk, buttermilk and eggs keep to their printed dates. The tomatoes and lettuce keep to their printed dates.
  • Freezer: The spare buns freeze for up to 1 month — next burger night is already started. The spare cheese slices freeze for up to 1 month. The spare ice cream keeps to its printed date in the freezer. Do not freeze the fried strips, the popcorn chicken or the pickle fries — eat them fresh. Do not freeze the blended shakes.
Crispy chicken strips in a basket with fries and a red dip

The Bottom Line

$55.96. Five dinners for four, $2.80 a serving, $11.19 a dinner — corn dogs with tots, chili cheese tots, double smash burgers, crispy chicken strips with Texas toast, and popcorn chicken with pickle fries and vanilla milkshakes, every one of them from a single shop, with about 26g of protein a serving on average, and exactly $125 less than the same five dinners at Sonic. Fifty-six dollars is not a tight week. It is five real fast-food dinners, with the golden corn dogs, the loaded tots, the crispy-edged smash burgers, the crunchy strips and the hand-spun shakes — the whole drive-thru, cooked at home, for the price of one night at the counter.

Read Next

Comments