The Copycat Subway Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $70.29 Shop — $3.51 a Serving

Delicious meatball sandwiches with parmesan

A 6-inch Meatball Marinara is $6.29 at Subway now. A 6-inch Steak & Cheese is $7.99. A family of four ordering one 6-inch sub each, five nights running — meatball, teriyaki chicken, tuna, Italian B.M.T. and steak and cheese — is looking at about $143.00 before tax, and that is without a single drink or a single chip.

This week cooks all five of those dinners at home. Five dinners for four, from a single $70.29 shop. That is $3.51 a serving and $14.06 a dinner for four. The same five dinners at Subway run about $143.00 — this week beats that by about $73. And the best part is the part the menu board never tells you: a sub is just a good roll, a filling you actually seasoned yourself, and cheese that melts all the way through. Once you have built one at home, the $7.99 never leaves your pocket again.

The Exact Shop

ItemPrice (approx. US supermarket)
Hoagie rolls, 6-count × 4$9.96
Ground beef, 1 lb$3.99
Marinara sauce, 24 oz jar$2.49
Chicken breast, 2 lb$5.98
Teriyaki sauce, 15 oz$2.49
Canned tuna, 5 oz × 4$4.96
Deli ham, 1 lb$4.49
Pepperoni, 6 oz$2.99
Salami, 8 oz$3.49
Thin-sliced steak, 1.5 lb$8.99
Provolone cheese slices, 8 oz$2.99
Shredded mozzarella, 8 oz$2.49
Mayonnaise, 15 oz$2.99
Green bell peppers, 2$1.58
Onions, 2 lb$1.19
Roma tomatoes, 4$1.96
Iceberg lettuce, 1 head$1.49
Dill pickle spears, 16 oz$2.49
Pepperoncini, 12 oz jar$2.49
Sweet onion, 1$0.79
Total$70.29
Delicious Italian sub sandwich with melted cheese

The math: $9.96 + $3.99 + $2.49 + $5.98 + $2.49 + $4.96 + $4.49 + $2.99 + $3.49 + $8.99 + $2.99 + $2.49 + $2.99 + $1.58 + $1.19 + $1.96 + $1.49 + $2.49 + $2.49 + $0.79 = $70.29. Five dinners for four = 20 servings. $70.29 ÷ 20 = $3.51 a serving. $70.29 ÷ 5 = $14.06 a dinner for four. The same five dinners at Subway run about $143.00 — this week beats that by about $73. Cooking oil, salt, pepper, garlic powder, Italian seasoning and red pepper flakes are pantry staples and are not costed.

The Method

Monday — Meatball Marinara subs, copycat: Mix the ground beef with diced onion, garlic powder, Italian seasoning and salt, roll it into 16 small meatballs and brown them in a hot pan, then simmer them in the marinara for ten minutes until they are cooked through and coated. Split four rolls, spoon four meatballs into each with plenty of sauce, top with shredded mozzarella and slide them under the broiler for two minutes until the cheese bubbles. The roll soaks up the sauce at the edges and stays soft in the middle — that is the whole sandwich, and it is the $6.29 one, at home for about $3.51 a serving.

Tuesday — Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki-style subs, copycat: Slice the chicken thin and cook it fast in a hot oiled pan with the sweet onion sliced into rings and one of the green peppers, then pour over the teriyaki sauce and let it glaze for two minutes until everything is glossy. Pile the chicken into four rolls, spoon the pan sauce over the top and add a few raw onion rings for crunch. The sweet-salty glaze is the flavor the restaurant version is built on — and at home you get to decide how much of it goes on.

Wednesday — Tuna melts, copycat: Drain the tuna and mix it with mayonnaise, diced onion and a pinch of red pepper flakes — one can per sub, so the filling is generous instead of the thin scrape the counter gives you. Split four rolls, fill them with the tuna mix, lay sliced tomato over the top and cover with shredded mozzarella, then broil for three minutes until the cheese melts and the edges of the roll go golden. The melt is the simplest dinner of the week, and the one that tastes the most like a treat for the least work.

Thursday — Italian B.M.T.-style subs, copycat: This is the cold night, and the fastest one. Split four rolls and spread mayonnaise on both sides, then layer each one the same way: ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, sliced tomato, dill pickles and pepperoncini. Press each sub down firmly and cut it on a diagonal — the press is what makes a deli sub hold together instead of falling apart in your hands. No cooking at all, and the plate looks like it came out of a sandwich shop.

Friday — Steak & cheese subs, copycat: Slice the steak as thin as you can and cook it fast in a very hot oiled pan with sliced onion and the second green pepper, breaking it up as it browns, then lay provolone over the top and let it melt into the meat. Pile the steak into four rolls and spoon the pan juices over the top — the juices soaking into the roll are the whole point of a cheesesteak, and the reason the home version beats the $7.99 one. One pan, the whole table eating with both hands, and the shop is empty by the end of the night.

Delicious tuna sandwich on focaccia bread

The Week at a Glance

  • Monday — Meatball Marinara subs copycat: The simmer night. Sixteen homemade meatballs in marinara with melted mozzarella, broiled in the roll — the $6.29 sub, at home for about $3.51 a serving.
  • Tuesday — Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki-style subs copycat: The glaze night. Sliced chicken, sweet onion and green pepper in teriyaki sauce, piled into rolls with the pan sauce spooned over — the $7.29 sub, built saucier than the restaurant's.
  • Wednesday — Tuna melts copycat: The broiler night. A full can of tuna per sub with mayonnaise, tomato and melted mozzarella, broiled until golden — the $6.99 sub, with a filling twice as generous as the counter's.
  • Thursday — Italian B.M.T.-style subs copycat: The no-cook night. Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, pickles and pepperoncini, pressed and cut on the diagonal — the $7.19 sub, and the fastest dinner of the week.
  • Friday — Steak & cheese subs copycat: The hot-pan night. Thin-sliced steak with onion and green pepper, provolone melted right into the meat, pan juices over the top — the $7.99 sub, and the dinner the week ends on.

The Subway Comparison

NightAt Subway (4 × 6-inch)At home (average)
Monday — Meatball Marinara × 4$25.16$14.06
Tuesday — Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki × 4$29.16$14.06
Wednesday — Tuna × 4$27.96$14.06
Thursday — Italian B.M.T. × 4$28.76$14.06
Friday — Steak & Cheese × 4$31.96$14.06
Week total$143.00$70.29

The saving: $143.00 − $70.29 = $72.71 — about $73 back in your pocket for the same five dinners. Every Subway price above is a verified November 2026 menu price: Meatball Marinara 6-inch $6.29, Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki 6-inch $7.29, Tuna 6-inch $6.99, Italian B.M.T. 6-inch $7.19 and Steak & Cheese 6-inch $7.99. Prices vary by location — Subway is all franchises — and tax is extra at the restaurant. One honest note: the restaurant versions come with nothing extra either — these are à la carte 6-inch prices, no drinks, no chips — so the comparison is like for like. And the home subs are fuller: a whole can of tuna per melt, four meatballs per roll, and steak piled instead of weighed.

Delicious melted cheese steak sub close-up

The Bottom Line

$70.29. Five dinners for four, $3.51 a serving, $14.06 a dinner — meatball marinara subs, teriyaki chicken subs, tuna melts, Italian B.M.T.s and steak and cheese subs, every one of them built the Subway way, and about $73 less than the same five dinners at the restaurant. A sub is a roll, a filling and melted cheese. Once you have built one at home, the $7.99 never leaves your pocket again.

Read Next

Comments