The Thanksgiving Leftovers Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $13.65 Shop — 68¢ a Serving

Thanksgiving leftovers

Thanksgiving is over, the dishes are done, and the fridge is full of turkey. Here is the part nobody tells you: that fridge is not leftovers. It is five more dinners, already paid for.

The $39 Aldi Thanksgiving dinner fed 10 people — and a 16-pound turkey leaves a family of four with roughly 4 pounds of cooked turkey meat, plus leftover stuffing, cranberry sauce, sweet potatoes and rolls. This week turns all of it into five completely different dinners for four, and the only new money is one small shop: $13.65. That is 68¢ a serving, $2.73 a dinner, and the turkey itself costs $0 extra because Thursday already bought it.

The Exact Shop

Flour tortillas, 10-count — $1.98
Shredded cheddar cheese, 8 oz — $1.89
Salsa, 16 oz jar — $1.79
Egg noodles, 12 oz — $1.29
Chicken broth, 32 oz carton — $1.85
Frozen peas & carrots, 12 oz — $1.19
Refrigerated pie crusts, 2-count — $1.89
Yellow onion, 1 — $0.79
Limes, 2 — $0.98
Total — $13.65

The math: $1.98 + $1.89 + $1.79 + $1.29 + $1.85 + $1.19 + $1.89 + $0.79 + $0.98 = $13.65. Five dinners × 4 servings = 20 servings. $13.65 ÷ 20 = 68¢ a serving (68.25¢, shown as 68¢). Already in the fridge from Thursday, at no extra cost: about 4 lb cooked turkey, leftover stuffing, leftover cranberry sauce, leftover mashed sweet potatoes, leftover Hawaiian rolls, leftover peas and carrots, and leftover pumpkin pie for dessert. Cooking oil, salt, pepper, garlic, soy sauce, flour and butter are pantry staples and are not costed — if your cupboard is completely empty, those are the only extras.

What the whole holiday really cost: Thanksgiving dinner $39.00 + this week's shop $13.65 = $52.65 for a 10-person holiday meal plus five more dinners for four — 30 servings at $1.76 each.

Turkey noodle soup

The Five Dinners

  1. Turkey Noodle Soup (Friday, Nov 27): The classic first move. Shredded turkey, egg noodles, diced onion and the leftover carrots and celery simmered in broth. The carcass goes in the pot first if you kept it — free stock, and the soup tastes like it cooked all day.
  2. Turkey Tacos (Saturday, Nov 28): The night that does not taste like Thanksgiving at all. Warm tortillas, turkey crisped in a pan with a squeeze of lime, shredded cheddar and salsa. Nobody at the table will call this leftovers.
  3. Turkey Pot Pie (Sunday, Nov 29): The comfort-night centerpiece. Turkey, frozen peas and carrots and diced onion in a creamy broth-and-milk sauce, baked under a golden pie crust. The second crust is the spare — it becomes Tuesday's shortcut if you want it.
  4. Turkey Shepherd's Pie (Monday, Nov 30): The leftover sweet potatoes earn their keep. Turkey and peas and carrots in broth underneath, a thick layer of mashed sweet potatoes on top, baked until the edges brown. Two Thanksgiving sides become one new dinner.
  5. Turkey Cranberry Melts (Tuesday, Dec 1): The clear-out. Leftover Hawaiian rolls split and filled with turkey, cheddar and cranberry sauce, pressed in a pan until the cheese melts and the rolls go golden. The last of the turkey, the last of the rolls, the last of the sauce — gone in one pan.

The Method (one Friday sort-out, then 20-minute nights)

  1. Friday morning — sort the fridge (10 minutes): Pull every container out. Shred or slice all the turkey and divide it into five rough portions — about ¾ lb per dinner, a little more for the pot pie. Put Tuesday's portion straight into the freezer: cooked turkey keeps 3–4 days in the fridge, and Tuesday is day five. Thaw it Monday night in the fridge.
  2. Friday — soup: If you kept the carcass, cover it with water and simmer 1 hour for stock; otherwise use the carton of broth. Sauté the diced onion in a little oil, add broth, leftover carrots and celery, and the egg noodles. Simmer 8 minutes, stir in the shredded turkey for the last 3 minutes, and season. Serve with leftover rolls.
  3. Saturday — tacos: Heat a little oil in a pan and crisp the turkey 4–5 minutes until the edges brown. Warm the tortillas in the same pan. Build: turkey, cheddar, salsa, a squeeze of lime. Two tacos per person, eight total — the 10-count pack leaves two spare.
  4. Sunday — pot pie: Sauté half the diced onion in butter, stir in a spoonful of flour, then slowly add about half the broth and a splash of milk until it thickens. Fold in the turkey and frozen peas and carrots. Pour into a pie dish, lay one crust on top, crimp the edges, cut a few steam slits, and bake at 400°F for about 25 minutes until golden.
  5. Monday — shepherd's pie: Simmer the turkey with the rest of the frozen peas and carrots, the remaining onion and a splash of broth until it thickens slightly. Spread in a baking dish, top with the leftover mashed sweet potatoes, and bake at 400°F for about 20 minutes until the top browns at the edges.
  6. Tuesday — melts: Thawed turkey, cheddar and cranberry sauce inside split Hawaiian rolls. Butter the outsides, press in a hot pan 2–3 minutes a side until golden and the cheese melts. Serve with the last of the salsa if any is left.

Turkey tacos

3 Variations (no extra shop)

  • No pie crusts in the shop? Skip the pot pie crust and top the same filling with leftover stuffing instead — a turkey-and-stuffing bake that uses the crust money for nothing. The shop drops by $1.89, to $11.76, which is 59¢ a serving.
  • Spicy tacos: A spoonful of salsa in the pan while the turkey crisps, plus the second lime squeezed over the top. Pantry heat, no extra cost, and it is the night that tastes least like Thursday.
  • Soup from the carcass: If you simmered the carcass Friday, you have homemade stock for the pot pie and shepherd's pie too — the carton of broth becomes next week's soup base instead, and nothing in the shop goes to waste.

Why This Works

  • The turkey is already paid for: The most expensive ingredient in all five dinners costs $0 this week. The $13.65 shop is only the supporting cast — tortillas, cheese, noodles, crusts — the things that turn one ingredient into five different meals.
  • Nothing tastes like a repeat: Soup, tacos, a pie, a bake and a melt. Five different pans, five different flavour profiles, and the only thing they share is the turkey. That is the whole trick of a leftovers week: change the format, not the ingredient.
  • The shop has no dead ends: Broth works three nights, the onion works three nights, cheddar works two, frozen veg works two. Tortillas, noodles and pie crusts are each the star of one night and cost under $2 each.
  • The freezer does the food-safety math: Cooked turkey keeps 3–4 days in the fridge. Freezing Tuesday's portion on Friday is what makes a five-day leftovers week safe instead of a gamble.

Storage

  • Fridge: Cooked turkey keeps 3–4 days in covered containers. The soup, pot pie and shepherd's pie keep 3–4 days too — reheat the soup on the stove and the pies in the oven so the crusts stay crisp.
  • Freezer: Shredded turkey freezes for up to 1 month — freeze in dinner-sized portions so you only thaw what you need. The soup (without noodles) freezes for up to 1 month; the shepherd's pie base freezes before the potato topping goes on.

A note on BJ's: If your turkey came free through BJ's instead of Aldi, this week works exactly the same — the bird still costs $0 extra. The BJ's window is narrow, so check it now: qualify by spending $150+ in a single transaction between October 31 and November 9, get the coupon from November 14, and claim the free Butterball (worth up to $25) by November 25. Miss the November 9 qualifying date and the free turkey is gone — but the Aldi $39 dinner this article is built on runs through November 25 either way.

Turkey pot pie

The Bottom Line

$13.65. Five dinners for four, 20 servings, 68¢ each — on top of a Thanksgiving dinner that already fed 10 for $39. The whole holiday, start to finish: $52.65 for 30 servings, $1.76 a plate. Twenty takeout turkey plates at about $13.99 each would run about $280 — this week beats that by about $266, and the food is already sitting in your fridge. The most expensive Thanksgiving mistake is throwing the leftovers away on Sunday. This is the week that does not.

Read Next

Comments