The Copycat Five Guys Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $91.19 Shop — $4.56 a Serving

Towering double smash burger with melted cheese, grilled mushrooms, bacon strips and creamy sauce on a glossy bun

Five Guys is the most expensive burger on this whole list, and it is also the simplest — five things on the menu, fifteen toppings that cost nothing, fries that come in a cup that overflows into the bag, and a bowl of peanuts on the table while you wait. There are no combos, no value menu, no chicken, no salads, no breakfast, and no drive-thru. This week cooks all five of those dinners at home. Cheeseburgers "all the way" on Monday, Little Bacon Cheeseburgers with jalapeños and Cajun fries on Tuesday, Bacon Cheese Dogs on Wednesday, Grilled Cheese BLTs on Thursday, and Double Bacon Cheeseburgers with Oreo shakes on Friday.

Five dinners for four, one $91.19 shop, $4.56 a serving — and about 40g of protein a serving on average. The same five dinners at Five Guys run about $372.76. This week beats that by about $282. Yes, $91.19 is the priciest shop in this whole series — Five Guys is the priciest burger chain in the series, and the saving is the biggest one too. The trick is the same one Five Guys uses: the menu is built from a handful of pieces — beef, bacon, buns, potatoes and a tub of vanilla ice cream — that just change shape every night. And the toppings are free. All fifteen of them, on every burger, every night, because a Five Guys burger with nothing on it is just a patty, and a Five Guys burger "all the way" is the whole point.

The Exact Shop

ItemPrice (approx. US supermarket)
Ground beef 80/20, 5 lb$19.95
Bacon, 16 oz ×2$11.98
Beef hot dogs, 8 ct$3.49
Hamburger buns, sesame, 8 ct ×2$4.98
Hot dog buns, 8 ct$1.99
White sandwich bread, 1 loaf$2.49
American cheese slices, 12 ct ×3$7.47
Russet potatoes, 5 lb$3.49
Peanuts, roasted in shell, 16 oz$2.99
Lettuce, 1 head$1.49
Tomatoes, 4$2.49
Yellow onions, 2$1.49
Mushrooms, 8 oz$1.99
Green bell peppers, 2$1.49
Jalapeños, fresh, 4 ct$0.99
Dill pickle chips, 16 oz jar$2.49
Sweet pickle relish, 12 oz$1.99
A.1. steak sauce, 10 oz$3.49
Mayonnaise, 12 oz$2.99
Cajun seasoning, 2 oz$2.49
Vanilla ice cream, 1.5 qt$3.99
Whole milk, 1/2 gal$1.99
Chocolate sandwich cookies, 14 oz$2.99
Total$91.19

The math: $19.95 + $11.98 + $3.49 + $4.98 + $1.99 + $2.49 + $7.47 + $3.49 + $2.99 + $1.49 + $2.49 + $1.49 + $1.99 + $1.49 + $0.99 + $2.49 + $1.99 + $3.49 + $2.99 + $2.49 + $3.99 + $1.99 + $2.99 = $91.19. Five dinners for four = 20 servings. $91.19 ÷ 20 = $4.56 a serving. $91.19 ÷ 5 = $18.24 a dinner for four. The same five dinners at Five Guys run about $372.76 — this week beats that by about $282. Cooking oil, salt, pepper, garlic powder, paprika, ketchup, yellow mustard, BBQ sauce and hot sauce are pantry staples and are not costed. One honest note about the oil: Five Guys fries everything in 100% peanut oil, and there are in-shell peanuts on every table — the shop's bag of peanuts is the nod to that. At home the fries cook in the pantry oil, so if anyone in the house has a peanut allergy, skip the peanuts and the home fries are still safe, because you control the oil. The beef is the priciest item in the shop at $19.95 for the whole week — it does three nights, Monday, Tuesday and Friday, and it earns it.

Single bacon cheeseburger with melted cheese and crispy bacon strips on a glossy bun, dark background

What Each Night Costs

NightDinnerProtein per serving (approx.)As takeout for fourAt home
MondayCheeseburgers "all the way" (doubles) + boardwalk fries~50g~$73.92$18.24
TuesdayLittle Bacon Cheeseburgers with jalapeños + Cajun fries~35g~$66.72$18.24
WednesdayBacon Cheese Dogs (2 each) + boardwalk fries~32g~$65.12$18.24
ThursdayGrilled Cheese BLTs + boardwalk fries~22g~$59.92$18.24
FridayDouble Bacon Cheeseburgers + boardwalk fries + Oreo shakes~60g~$107.08$18.24
Week total5 dinners, 20 servings~40g average~$372.76$91.19

The saving: $372.76 − $91.19 = $281.57 — about $282 back in your pocket for the same five dinners. Every takeout price above is approximate: the Five Guys prices are typical US Five Guys menu prices from independent menu guides (Cheeseburger ~$11.99, Little Bacon Cheeseburger ~$10.19, Bacon Cheese Dog ~$9.79, BLT ~$8.49, Bacon Cheeseburger ~$13.69, Regular Fries ~$6.49, Cajun Fries ~$6.49, vanilla shake ~$6.59 per person — see the Verification Note in the draft), prices vary by location, and tax is extra at the restaurant. The comparison is like for like — entrées plus the fries and shake that come with them, no drinks — and the home dinners are bigger: two full 4-oz patties each on Monday and Friday, a full 4-oz patty with bacon each on Tuesday, two loaded dogs each on Wednesday, a whole grilled cheese BLT each on Thursday, and a shake each on Friday, with seconds for anyone who wants them. One honest note: Thursday is the lightest protein night of the week at about 22g a serving — a grilled cheese BLT is a sandwich, not a steak, and the bacon does what it can — while Friday is the heaviest at about 60g, because two patties plus bacon plus cheese plus a milk shake do the work on their own. Friday does the heavy lifting on the saving — the double bacon cheeseburger plate is the priciest plate on the board at about $26.77 a serving, and the home version saves about $89 that night alone — and the week still comes out about $282 ahead.

The Week at a Glance

  • Monday — Cheeseburgers "all the way" (doubles) with boardwalk fries (~50g protein): The signature night. Four double burgers — two 4-oz patties each, two slices of American, grilled mushrooms, grilled onions, grilled green peppers, lettuce, tomato, pickles, relish, mayo and a spoonful of A.1. on toasted sesame buns — with a pile of fresh-cut boardwalk fries. The burger that built the chain, at home, with every topping free.
  • Tuesday — Little Bacon Cheeseburgers with jalapeños + Cajun fries (~35g protein): The single-patty night. One 4-oz patty each with cheese, two strips of bacon, sliced jalapeños and A.1. on toasted sesame buns, with the fries tossed in Cajun seasoning while they are still hot. The same burger as Monday, one patty lighter, with a kick — and the cheapest burger night of the week.
  • Wednesday — Bacon Cheese Dogs, two each, + boardwalk fries (~32g protein): The dog night. All-beef hot dogs split lengthwise and grilled until the cut faces caramelise, laid in toasted buns with a slice of melted American and a strip of bacon each, with any of the fifteen free toppings on top. Two dogs each, because one Five Guys dog is never enough.
  • Thursday — Grilled Cheese BLTs + boardwalk fries (~22g protein): The sandwich night. White bread grilled golden with two slices of melted American, then opened up and filled with crispy bacon, lettuce and tomato — the grilled cheese and the BLT in one sandwich, the way the menu lets you build it. The only night in the week with no beef, and the one the kids will ask for again first.
  • Friday — Double Bacon Cheeseburgers + boardwalk fries + Oreo shakes (~60g protein): The finish night. Four double burgers with bacon, cheese, grilled onions, green peppers and A.1., with a tray of boardwalk fries and a vanilla shake each, blended thick with crushed chocolate sandwich cookies — the Oreo mix-in, free at the counter, crushed at home. The most expensive plate on the board, at home, for the price of the fries alone.

The Method

The Five Guys rules — the same five rules, every night

1. The toppings are free — all fifteen of them. Mayo, ketchup, mustard, relish, raw onions, grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, green peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, jalapeños, A.1. sauce, BBQ sauce and hot sauce. At the counter they cost nothing, so at home the only topping you pay for is the bottle of A.1. — and it does three nights' work.

2. Fresh, never frozen — form, don't press. The patties are hand-formed from fresh beef and cooked to order. Press them once, gently, when you form them — and then never press them on the grill. Pressing a patty while it cooks squeezes the juices out, and the crust comes from leaving it alone.

3. The boardwalk fries are the through-line. Five pounds of russet potatoes cover all five nights — about 1 lb beside every dinner, Cajun-seasoned on Tuesday — so the cheapest item in the shop does five nights' work. Cut them skin-on, soak them in cold water, fry them twice.

4. Peanuts while you wait. The bag of in-shell peanuts is the table snack, the way every Five Guys table has one. Crack them while the burgers cook — that is the whole ritual, and it costs $2.99 for the week.

5. Friday blends the shakes last. The shakes get blended while the burgers rest, and poured at the table. Blended early they melt, blended last they are thick enough to need a spoon. Hot burger, cold shake — that contrast is the whole Friday dinner.

Monday — Cheeseburgers "all the way" (doubles) + boardwalk fries: Cut about 1 lb of russet potatoes into skin-on sticks, soak them in cold water for 20 minutes, and pat them dry — the soak is what keeps them from sticking together. Heat the oil in a deep pot or fryer to 325°F and fry the potatoes once, gently, for 4 minutes, then lift them out and let them rest — they finish on the second fry. While they rest, slice 1 tomato and shred the lettuce. Slice the mushrooms, 1 onion and 1 green pepper, and grill them together in a hot pan with a little oil until soft and marked — the grilled toppings are what make this burger "all the way" instead of just a cheeseburger. Divide 2 lb of the beef into eight 4-oz balls and form each one into a patty, wider than the bun, because they shrink — then grill or sear them 3 minutes a side without pressing them down. While they rest, toast the cut sides of 4 sesame buns in the same pan until golden. Fry the potatoes a second time at 375°F for 3 minutes until golden and crisp, and salt them the second they come out. Build the burgers on the toasted buns: mayo on the bottom, then two patties, two slices of American, the grilled mushrooms, onions and peppers, tomato, lettuce, pickles, relish and a spoonful of A.1. Serve with the boardwalk fries and the peanuts on the table. The toppings are what make the burger — a double patty without them is just a burger, and the grilled mushrooms with the A.1. are the whole reason the chain has a line out the door.

Storage note: The cooked patties keep 2 days in the fridge and reheat in a pan; the fries do not keep — cook them fresh on the night.

Tuesday — Little Bacon Cheeseburgers with jalapeños + Cajun fries: Cut about 1 lb of russet potatoes into skin-on sticks, soak them in cold water for 20 minutes, and pat them dry. Heat the oil to 325°F and fry the potatoes once for 4 minutes, then lift them out and let them rest. While they rest, slice 1 tomato and shred the rest of the lettuce, and slice the jalapeños thin — the seeds are the heat, so leave them in for the adults and take them out for the kids. Fry 8 slices of bacon in a pan until crisp, then set them aside — keep the bacon fat in the pan, because the patties go in next and the fat is flavour. Divide 1 lb of beef into four 4-oz balls, form them into patties wider than the bun, and sear them in the bacon fat 3 minutes a side without pressing them down. While they rest, toast the cut sides of 4 more sesame buns in the pan until golden. Fry the potatoes a second time at 375°F for 3 minutes until golden and crisp, and toss them with the Cajun seasoning the second they come out — the seasoning only sticks while the fries are still hot and oily. Build the burgers on the toasted buns: mayo on the bottom, then the patty, a slice of American, two strips of bacon, jalapeños and a spoonful of A.1. Serve with the Cajun fries. The single patty is the whole point of a Little — the same burger as Monday, one patty lighter, and the jalapeños do the work the second patty used to do.

Make-ahead: The potatoes can be cut and soaked on Monday night — Tuesday is fry, sear, build, eat.

Storage note: The cooked patties keep 2 days in the fridge and reheat in a pan; the bacon keeps 3 days; the fries do not keep — cook them fresh on the night.

Two fully loaded hot dogs with mustard and sauce drizzle held up in hands against a black background

Wednesday — Bacon Cheese Dogs (2 each) + boardwalk fries: Cut about 1 lb of russet potatoes into skin-on sticks, soak them in cold water for 20 minutes, and pat them dry. Heat the oil to 325°F and fry the potatoes once for 4 minutes, then lift them out and let them rest. While they rest, dice the rest of the onion and cut the pickle chips into strips. Fry 8 slices of bacon in a pan until crisp, then set them aside. Split the 8 hot dogs lengthwise — not all the way through, just deep enough that they open flat — and grill them cut-side down in a hot pan until the faces caramelise and the dogs curl at the edges. Warm the 8 hot dog buns alongside them. Fry the potatoes a second time at 375°F for 3 minutes until golden and crisp, and salt them the second they come out. Build the dogs: a slice of American in the bottom of each bun, then the grilled dog, a strip of bacon, diced onion, relish and pickle strips, with mustard and ketchup from the pantry on top. Serve two dogs each with the boardwalk fries. The split is what makes the dog — a whole hot dog is just a hot dog, and a split dog grilled cut-side down has twice the caramelised surface.

Storage note: The grilled hot dogs keep 2 days in the fridge and reheat in a pan; the bacon keeps 3 days; the fries do not keep — cook them fresh on the night.

Thursday — Grilled Cheese BLTs + boardwalk fries: Cut about 1 lb of russet potatoes into skin-on sticks, soak them in cold water for 20 minutes, and pat them dry. Heat the oil to 325°F and fry the potatoes once for 4 minutes, then lift them out and let them rest. While they rest, fry 8 slices of bacon in a pan until crisp, then set them aside. Slice 1 tomato and shred the rest of the lettuce. Brush the outside of 8 slices of white bread with a little of the bacon fat from the pan, lay two slices of American on 4 of them, and grill them in the pan over medium heat until the bread is golden and the cheese melts — about 3 minutes a side, pressing gently with a spatula so the cheese meets the bread. Open each grilled cheese up, lay two strips of bacon, a smear of mayo, a slice of tomato and a little lettuce inside, and close it again. Fry the potatoes a second time at 375°F for 3 minutes until golden and crisp, and salt them the second they come out. Serve a grilled cheese BLT each with the boardwalk fries. The BLT is what makes the grilled cheese — a plain grilled cheese is just a sandwich, and the bacon, lettuce and tomato are the whole reason this is a dinner instead of a snack.

Storage note: The grilled cheese BLTs keep 1 day in the fridge and reheat best in the oven — the microwave turns the bread soft and the cheese runs out.

Friday — Double Bacon Cheeseburgers + boardwalk fries + Oreo shakes: Cut about 1 lb of russet potatoes into skin-on sticks, soak them in cold water for 20 minutes, and pat them dry. Heat the oil to 325°F and fry the potatoes once for 4 minutes, then lift them out and let them rest. While they rest, crush about 8 chocolate sandwich cookies in a bag with a rolling pin — not to dust, to crumbs, because the shake wants pieces. Fry 8 slices of bacon in a pan until crisp, then set them aside — keep the bacon fat in the pan, because the patties go in next and the fat is flavour. Divide the last 2 lb of beef into eight 4-oz balls, form them into patties wider than the bun, and sear them in the bacon fat 3 minutes a side without pressing them down. While they rest, toast the cut sides of the last 4 sesame buns in the pan until golden. Slice the last tomato and shred the last of the lettuce, and grill the last of the green peppers with the rest of the onion. Fry the potatoes a second time at 375°F for 3 minutes until golden and crisp, and salt them the second they come out. Blend the shakes last: about 24 oz of vanilla ice cream with the milk, in short pulses, until thick and just combined, then stir the cookie crumbs through — over-blending melts them, under-blending leaves them plain. Build the burgers on the toasted buns: mayo on the bottom, then two patties, two slices of American, two strips of bacon, grilled onions and peppers, tomato, lettuce and a spoonful of A.1. Serve with the boardwalk fries and a shake each. One honest note about the shake: real Five Guys shakes are hand-spun from vanilla ice cream with free mix-ins, and the Oreo mix-in is the most-ordered one — the shop's vanilla ice cream with crushed chocolate sandwich cookies is the same build, blended at home, and it eats like the shake, not like a glass of milk. The shakes want to be blended last — blended early they melt, blended last they are thick enough to need a spoon.

Storage note: The cooked patties keep 2 days in the fridge and reheat in a pan; the bacon keeps 3 days; the shakes do not keep — blend them fresh on the night.

3 Variations (no extra shop)

  • Double Little Burgers Tuesday: Split Tuesday's 4 patties into 8 thin 2-oz patties and stack two per burger with a slice of American each. Same $91.19 shop, same burgers, and Tuesday's dinner comes out a double stack instead of a single — the cheese that was going to wait for next week does its work on the patties instead.
  • A.1. and jalapeño Monday: Move Tuesday's jalapeños and the A.1. onto Monday's doubles instead of Tuesday's singles. Same shop, same burgers, and the mildest burger night of the week suddenly has a kick — the kids can pick the plain doubles and the adults take the spicy ones.
  • Cheese boardwalk fries Friday: Melt 4 of the spare American slices over Friday's fries instead of saving them. Same $91.19 shop, same burgers, and Friday's fries come out loaded instead of plain — the cheese that was going to wait for next week does its work on the fries instead.

Why This Works

  • Five Guys' whole menu is four moves: A hand-formed patty, a split dog, a grilled sandwich and a blended shake. One shop covers all five dinners because the menu itself is built from the same few pieces — the beef, the bacon, the buns and the potatoes just change shape every night.
  • The fifteen free toppings are the cheapest luxury in the shop: A spoonful of A.1., a pile of grilled mushrooms and a handful of jalapeños turn a plain double patty into a Five Guys burger. Nothing else in the shop does that much work for that little money — the toppings are what make five nights taste like the restaurant.
  • One shop, five completely different dinners: Cheeseburgers "all the way", Little bacon burgers with Cajun fries, split bacon cheese dogs, grilled cheese BLTs, double bacon burgers with Oreo shakes — the method changes every night (grill, sear, split-and-grill, griddle, sear), so the week never tastes like the same dinner five times, even though the same twenty-three items supply all of it.
  • It beats Five Guys by about $282: Five nights at the counter for a family of four run about $372.76. This week is $91.19, the dinners are bigger, the portions are full, and the shake is blended at home.
  • Every dinner carries 22g of protein or more a serving: Thursday trails at about 22g, Friday leads at about 60g, and the week averages about 40g — the menu changes, the protein doesn't drop below a sandwich's share.

Storage

  • Fridge: The cooked burger patties keep 2 days and reheat in a pan; the grilled hot dogs keep 2 days and reheat in a pan; the grilled cheese BLTs keep 1 day and reheat best in the oven; the bacon keeps 3 days; the mayonnaise keeps to its printed date. The tomatoes and lettuce keep to their printed dates.
  • Freezer: The spare American slices freeze for up to 1 month — next burger night is already started. The spare sesame buns freeze for up to 1 month. The spare ice cream keeps to its printed date in the freezer. The spare cookies keep to their printed date. Do not freeze the cooked patties, the grilled hot dogs or the grilled cheese BLTs once cooked — eat them fresh. Do not freeze the blended shakes.
Cookies-and-cream milkshake with chocolate drizzle in a tall glass, beside a plate of chocolate chip cookies

The Bottom Line

$91.19. Five dinners for four, $4.56 a serving, $18.24 a dinner — cheeseburgers "all the way", Little Bacon Cheeseburgers with jalapeños and Cajun fries, Bacon Cheese Dogs, Grilled Cheese BLTs, and Double Bacon Cheeseburgers with Oreo shakes, every one of them from a single shop, with about 40g of protein a serving on average, and about $282 less than the same five dinners at Five Guys. Ninety-one dollars is not a tight week. It is five real fast-food dinners, with the double patty, the single with a kick, the split dog, the grilled cheese BLT and the double bacon burger with a shake — the whole Five Guys counter, cooked at home, for less than the price of one night at the counter. And the peanuts are free, the way they always are.

Read Next

Comments