The Copycat Olive Garden Week: 5 Dinners for Four, One $86.77 Shop — $4.34 a Serving

Delicious soup served with garlic bread, kale, and fresh loaf on a table

A bowl of Zuppa Toscana is $10.99 at Olive Garden now — and that is the soup, salad and breadsticks before you have even ordered a main. A plate of shrimp scampi is $21.49. A chicken marsala is $20.99. A family of four ordering the five things Olive Garden is actually famous for — Zuppa Toscana with salad and breadsticks, five cheese ziti al forno, chicken marsala, shrimp scampi and lasagna classico — is looking at about $365.00 before tax, and that is without a single drink. This week cooks all five of those dinners at home, from a single $86.77 shop. That is $4.34 a serving and $17.35 a dinner for four. The same five dinners from Olive Garden run about $365.00 — this week beats that by about $278. And the best part is the part the menu never tells you: Olive Garden's whole menu is soup, pasta and one baked classic, and one shop of sausage, pasta, five cheeses, chicken, shrimp and beef covers all five nights — the marinara is Tuesday's ziti and Friday's lasagna, the mozzarella and ricotta are Tuesday and Friday too, and the garlic is in every single pan.

The Exact Shop

ItemPrice (approx. US supermarket)
Italian sausage, 1 lb$3.49
Russet potatoes, 2 lb$1.49
Kale, 1 bunch$1.49
Chicken broth, 32 oz × 2$3.98
Heavy cream, 1 pint$2.49
Bacon, 12 oz$4.49
Romaine lettuce, 1 head$1.49
Italian dressing, 16 oz$2.49
Refrigerated breadstick dough, 11 oz$2.99
Ziti pasta, 1 lb$1.29
Marinara sauce, 24 oz × 2$4.98
Mozzarella, 16 oz$3.99
Ricotta, 15 oz$2.99
Parmesan, 5 oz$2.99
Provolone, 6 oz$2.49
Romano, 5 oz$2.99
Chicken breast, 2 lb$5.98
Mushrooms, 8 oz$1.99
Marsala wine, 750 ml$4.99
Spaghetti, 1 lb$1.29
Raw shrimp, 1 lb$7.99
Linguine, 1 lb$1.29
Asparagus, 1 bunch$2.49
Tomatoes, 1 lb$1.49
Ground beef, 1 lb$4.49
Lasagna noodles, 12 oz$1.99
Garlic, 1 head$0.69
Yellow onions, 2 lb$1.49
Butter, 8 oz$2.49
Eggs, 6-count$1.99
Total$86.77

The math: $3.49 + $1.49 + $1.49 + $3.98 + $2.49 + $4.49 + $1.49 + $2.49 + $2.99 + $1.29 + $4.98 + $3.99 + $2.99 + $2.99 + $2.49 + $2.99 + $5.98 + $1.99 + $4.99 + $1.29 + $7.99 + $1.29 + $2.49 + $1.49 + $4.49 + $1.99 + $0.69 + $1.49 + $2.49 + $1.99 = $86.77. Five dinners for four = 20 servings. $86.77 ÷ 20 = $4.34 a serving. $86.77 ÷ 5 = $17.35 a dinner for four. The same five dinners from Olive Garden run about $365.00 — this week beats that by about $278. Cooking oil, olive oil, salt, black pepper, dried Italian seasoning, dried basil, dried oregano, red pepper flakes and sugar are pantry staples and are not costed. The Italian sausage, potatoes, kale, bacon and breadstick dough are Monday only; the chicken broth is Monday's soup (6 cups) with 2 cups spare for Thursday's pan; the marinara splits 1 jar Tuesday and 1 jar Friday; the mozzarella splits 8 oz Tuesday and 8 oz Friday; the ricotta splits Tuesday and Friday; the parmesan splits Tuesday and Friday with a spoonful over Thursday's scampi; the chicken breast, mushrooms, marsala wine and spaghetti are Wednesday only; the shrimp, linguine and asparagus are Thursday only; the ground beef and lasagna noodles are Friday only — so nothing in the shop is wasted except small pantry spares (cream, romano, eggs) that cover Saturday.

Close-up of rigatoni pasta topped with melted cheese and herbs

What Each Night Costs

NightDinnerAt Olive Garden for fourAt home
MondayZuppa Toscana soup + house salad + breadsticks~$43.96$17.35
TuesdayFive Cheese Ziti al Forno~$73.96$17.35
WednesdayChicken Marsala + spaghetti~$83.96$17.35
ThursdayShrimp Scampi + linguine~$85.96$17.35
FridayLasagna Classico~$77.16$17.35
Week total5 dinners, 20 servings~$365.00$86.77

The saving: $365.00 − $86.77 = $278.23 — about $278 back in your pocket for the same five dinners. Every Olive Garden price above is approximate: the takeout prices are typical US Olive Garden menu prices (soup, salad & breadsticks ~$10.99, five cheese ziti al forno ~$18.49, chicken marsala ~$20.99, shrimp scampi ~$21.49, lasagna classico ~$19.29 per person), prices vary by location, and tax is extra at the restaurant. The comparison is like for like — food only, no drinks — and the home dinners are bigger: a full pot of soup instead of four small bowls, a whole baking dish of ziti, and a lasagna that feeds four with lunch left over. One honest note: Monday is the smallest win of the week — four soup-salad-breadsticks run only about $43.96 at Olive Garden, so the home version saves about $27 that night. Thursday is the biggest win — four shrimp scampis run $85.96, so the home version saves about $69 that night alone — and the week still comes out about $278 ahead.

The Week at a Glance

  • Monday — Zuppa Toscana soup + house salad + breadsticks, copycat: The soup-salad-breadsticks night. Italian sausage browned with bacon, sliced russet potatoes and kale simmered in chicken broth and finished with cream, with a chopped romaine salad in Italian dressing and warm breadsticks from the tube. The $10.99 soup-salad-breadsticks, at home for about $4.34 a serving — and the breadsticks are the dinner's trick, warm from the oven while the soup is still steaming.
  • Tuesday — Five Cheese Ziti al Forno, copycat: The baked night. Ziti tossed in marinara and layered with all five cheeses — mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, provolone and romano — then baked until the top goes golden and bubbly. The $18.49 baked pasta, at home for about $4.34 a serving — and the five cheeses are the whole trick, five different melts in one dish.
  • Wednesday — Chicken Marsala + spaghetti, copycat: The pan-sauce night. Chicken breast pan-seared golden, then simmered in a mushroom and marsala wine sauce with butter, served over spaghetti. The $20.99 chicken marsala, at home for about $4.34 a serving — and the marsala is the whole trick, one bottle that turns a plain chicken breast into the restaurant dish.
  • Thursday — Shrimp Scampi + linguine, copycat: The fancy night. A pound of shrimp sautéed in garlic butter, tossed with linguine, asparagus and tomatoes, finished with parmesan. The $21.49 shrimp scampi, at home for about $4.34 a serving — and the shrimp are the whole trick, the priciest thing in the shop and still the cheapest night to beat.
  • Friday — Lasagna Classico, copycat: The baked-classic night. Lasagna noodles layered with seasoned ground beef, marinara, ricotta mixed with egg, and mozzarella, baked until the cheese pulls. The $19.29 lasagna, at home for about $4.34 a serving — and the shop is empty by the end of it, because the last of the marinara, the last of the mozzarella, the last of the ricotta and the last of the tomatoes all go in on Friday.

The Method

Monday — Zuppa Toscana soup + house salad + breadsticks

Cook the 12 oz of bacon in a large pot until crisp, then lift it out and crumble it. Brown the 1 lb of Italian sausage in the same pot, breaking it up as it cooks, then add a diced onion and 2 minced garlic cloves and cook 2 minutes. Pour in both cartons of chicken broth, add the 2 lb of russet potatoes sliced thin, and simmer 15 minutes until the potatoes are tender. Stir in the chopped kale and 1 cup of heavy cream and simmer 5 minutes more until the kale wilts, then stir the bacon and sausage back in. While the soup simmers, chop the romaine, toss it with Italian dressing, and bake the breadstick dough per the tube — about 12 minutes until golden. Serve the soup with the salad and the warm breadsticks. The potatoes go in sliced thin, not diced — thin slices cook in 15 minutes and drink up the broth, and thick chunks stay hard in the middle.
Make-ahead: The potatoes can be sliced on Sunday night and kept in water in the fridge — Monday is a ten-minute start, and the pot does the rest.

Tuesday — Five Cheese Ziti al Forno

Heat the oven to 375°F and cook the 1 lb of ziti in salted water until just shy of done — a minute less than the box says — then drain it. While the pasta cooks, stir one jar of marinara into a bowl with the ricotta, half the mozzarella, the provolone torn into pieces, half the parmesan and half the romano. Toss the hot ziti through the cheese and sauce, tip it into a baking dish, and top with the rest of the mozzarella, parmesan and romano. Bake 20–25 minutes until the top is golden and bubbling at the edges. The ziti goes in undercooked on purpose — it finishes in the oven, and pasta that is fully cooked before it bakes turns to mush.
Storage note: The baked ziti keeps 3 days in the fridge and reheats best covered in the oven — the microwave dries out the top. A square of it cold is Friday's lunch.

Delicious shrimp pasta served in a ceramic bowl on a marble surface

Wednesday — Chicken Marsala + spaghetti

Put a pot of salted water on for the spaghetti. Slice the 2 lb of chicken breast into 8 thin cutlets and season with salt and pepper. Melt 2 oz of butter in a large pan over medium-high heat and sear the cutlets 3–4 minutes a side until golden, then lift them out. In the same pan, cook the sliced mushrooms and a diced onion with 2 minced garlic cloves for 4 minutes until the mushrooms give up their water. Pour in a good splash of the marsala wine — about 3/4 cup — and scrape the browned bits off the pan, then simmer 2 minutes until the sauce thickens slightly. Stir in another ounce of butter, slide the chicken back in and simmer 3 minutes until it is cooked through. Serve over the spaghetti with the pan sauce spooned over the top. The chicken comes out of the pan before the sauce is built — cooked in the sauce, it goes tough; rested and returned at the end, it stays tender.
Make-ahead: The chicken can be sliced into cutlets on Tuesday night and kept in the fridge — Wednesday is a fifteen-minute pan job and nothing needs chopping.

Thursday — Shrimp Scampi + linguine

Put a pot of salted water on for the linguine. Melt 3 oz of butter in a large pan over medium-high heat with a drizzle of olive oil, add 2 minced garlic cloves and a pinch of red pepper flakes, and cook 30 seconds until fragrant. Add the 1 lb of shrimp and cook 2 minutes a side until pink and just curled, then lift them out. Tip the asparagus, cut into short pieces, and the diced tomatoes into the same pan and cook 3 minutes, then pour in a splash of the spare chicken broth and simmer 1 minute. Toss in the drained linguine and the shrimp, add a spoonful of parmesan, and toss for 1 minute until everything is coated. The shrimp come out of the pan before the pasta goes in — cooked in the sauce, they go rubbery; tossed in at the end, they stay plump.
Storage note: The scampi is best eaten fresh — shrimp go tough overnight and the pasta drinks the sauce. Any spare asparagus keeps 2 days in the fridge and covers Saturday's eggs.

Friday — Lasagna Classico

Heat the oven to 375°F and cook the lasagna noodles in salted water until pliable, then drain them. While they cook, brown the 1 lb of ground beef with a diced onion and 2 minced garlic cloves, then stir in the second jar of marinara and the diced tomatoes and simmer 10 minutes. Whisk the ricotta with 2 beaten eggs and a pinch of salt. Spread a spoonful of sauce in a baking dish, then layer: noodles, ricotta, beef sauce, mozzarella — repeat three times, finishing with sauce and the last of the mozzarella and parmesan. Cover with foil and bake 30 minutes, then uncover and bake 10 minutes more until the top is golden and bubbling. Rest 10 minutes before cutting — cut it hot and the layers slide apart instead of holding their shape.
Storage note: The lasagna keeps 3–4 days in the fridge and reheats beautifully — it is better on Saturday than it was on Friday, and a square of it is Saturday lunch.

The Takeout Comparison

NightAt Olive Garden for fourAt home (average)
Monday — Soup, Salad & Breadsticks~$43.96$17.35
Tuesday — Five Cheese Ziti al Forno~$73.96$17.35
Wednesday — Chicken Marsala~$83.96$17.35
Thursday — Shrimp Scampi~$85.96$17.35
Friday — Lasagna Classico~$77.16$17.35
Week total~$365.00$86.77

The saving: $365.00 − $86.77 = $278.23 — about $278 back in your pocket for the same five dinners. Every Olive Garden price above is approximate: the takeout prices are typical US Olive Garden menu prices (soup, salad & breadsticks ~$10.99, five cheese ziti al forno ~$18.49, chicken marsala ~$20.99, shrimp scampi ~$21.49, lasagna classico ~$19.29 per person), prices vary by location, and tax is extra at the restaurant. The comparison is like for like — food only, no drinks — and the home dinners are bigger: a full pot of soup instead of four small bowls, a whole baking dish of ziti, and a lasagna that feeds four with lunch left over.

3 Variations (no extra shop)

  • Spicy Zuppa Toscana Monday: Stir red pepper flakes from the pantry into the soup before the cream goes in, and add a pinch to the salad dressing. Same $86.77 shop, same soup, and the mildest night of the week suddenly has a kick — the kids can take the plain bowls and the adults take the spicy ones.
  • Lasagna-style ziti Tuesday: Hold back half the ricotta and mozzarella from Friday's lasagna and layer Tuesday's ziti in the baking dish instead of tossing it — sauce, ziti, ricotta, mozzarella, repeat. Same $86.77 shop, same ziti, and Tuesday's baked pasta eats like a lasagna a day early — the cheeses that were waiting for Friday do their work a night early.
  • Extra-parmesan scampi Thursday: Scatter the spare parmesan generously over Thursday's scampi instead of saving it all for Friday. Same $86.77 shop, same shrimp, and the fanciest night of the week gets even fancier — the parmesan that was going to sit in the fridge does its work over the shrimp instead.

Why This Works

  • Olive Garden's menu is five moves from one Italian pantry: Soup, baked pasta, pan-seared chicken, garlic shrimp and layered lasagna are all built from the same few pieces — pasta, marinara, cheese, garlic and butter just change shape every night. That is why one $86.77 shop stretches across five completely different dinners.
  • The cheeses do the heavy lifting and never run short: Five cheeses go into Tuesday's ziti, then mozzarella, ricotta and parmesan come back for Friday's lasagna, with a spoonful of parmesan over Thursday's scampi in between. Every dinner gets its own cheese, and no cheese is bought for a single night.
  • The pasta changes shape so nobody notices it is pasta four nights running: Ziti on Tuesday, spaghetti on Wednesday, linguine on Thursday, lasagna on Friday — four nights of pasta that never taste the same, because one is baked, one is sauced, one is garlicky and one is layered.
  • The proteins never repeat: Sausage on Monday, no meat at all on Tuesday, chicken on Wednesday, shrimp on Thursday, beef on Friday. Five nights, five different mains, and nobody at the table notices the shop only bought five proteins.
  • It beats Olive Garden by about $278: Five Olive Garden dinners for a family of four run about $365.00. This week is $86.77, the dinners are bigger, the portions are full, and the only thing that shows up at the counter is the breadstick dough you already bought.

Storage

  • Fridge: The Zuppa Toscana keeps 3–4 days and reheats gently — the potatoes keep drinking, so add a splash of broth or water when you reheat it. The baked ziti keeps 3 days and reheats best covered in the oven. The chicken marsala keeps 2 days and reheats gently in a pan with a splash of water. The shrimp scampi is best fresh — shrimp go tough overnight. The lasagna keeps 3–4 days and is better the next day. The breadsticks are best fresh; the romaine salad keeps 1 day undressed. The marsala wine, Italian dressing and parmesan keep to their printed dates.
  • Freezer: The Zuppa Toscana base (before the cream goes in) freezes for up to 1 month; add the cream fresh when you reheat it. The lasagna freezes for up to 1 month — cool it first, freeze it in squares, and reheat covered. The baked ziti freezes for up to 1 month in single portions. Do not freeze the chicken marsala sauce, the shrimp scampi or the breadsticks — the sauce splits, the shrimp go rubbery and the bread goes stale.
Homemade lasagna garnished with tomato and basil sauce

The Bottom Line

$86.77. Five dinners for four, $4.34 a serving, $17.35 a dinner — Zuppa Toscana soup with salad and breadsticks, five cheese ziti al forno, chicken marsala, shrimp scampi and lasagna classico, every one of them built the Olive Garden way, and about $278 less than the same five dinners at the restaurant. Eighty-six dollars is not a tight week. It is the whole Italian-American menu, cooked at home, for the price of one night of shrimp scampi for four — and the breadsticks that made it all cost $2.99.

Read Next

Comments